Loading...
12-01-2021 Called Meeting Agenda Packet BOARD OF SUPERVISORS CALLED MEETING Wednesday, December 1, 2021 – 5:00 PM Board Meeting Room 39 Bank Street, SE, Chatham, Virginia 24531 AGENDA 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL APPROVAL OF AGENDA NEW BUSINESS a.Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at Board's December Business Meeting (Staff Contact: Dave F. Arnold) ADJOURNMENT Board of Supervisors EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ACTION ITEM Agenda Title: Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at Board's December Business Meeting (Staff Contact: Dave F. Arnold) Staff Contact(s): Dave F. Arnold Agenda Date: December 01, 2021 Item Number: 4.a Attachment(s): Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts Plan A Plan B Plan C Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing Reviewed By: SUMMARY: As required by Virginia Code § 24.2-304.1, the County is currently in the redistricting process. This process must take place every ten (10) years based on the United States Census, and the goal is for every Magisterial District to have roughly equal population. Virginia Code § 24.2- 129 requires the County allow Public Comment on the potential Redistricting Plans. Said Public Comment was held at the Board’s November 16, 2021, Business Meeting, where only one (1) citizen signed up to speak. For the Board’s review and consideration, all three (3) redistricting plans and the related redistricting presentation are attached. FINANCIAL IMPACT AND FUNDING SOURCE: Not applicable. RECOMMENDATION: County Staff recommends the Board choose a redistricting plan to advertise for potential adoption at the Board’s December Business Meeting, following the legally required Public Hearing. MOTION: For the Board’s review and consideration. 4.a Packet Pg. 2 Redistricting in Virginia Governing Criteria and Guidelines From Virginia Division of Legislative Services’ “Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021” http://dls.virginia.gov/pubs/redist/Redist2021.pdf 1 4.a.a Packet Pg. 3 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for 2 4.a.a Packet Pg. 4 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for 3 4.a.a Packet Pg. 5 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for 4 4.a.a Packet Pg. 6 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for 5 4.a.a Packet Pg. 7 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Page 19 of 54 5. Legal Standards Applicable to Local Redistricting 5.1. Introduction There are a number of legal tests and standards that are used to measure the validity of redistricting plans. The following sections outline and provide a general overview of those standards that should be kept in mind when drawing plans and that will be used to evaluate the plans after the fact. 5.2. Equal Population Equal population is the most fundamental requirement of redistricting for congressional, state legislative, and local election districts, rooted in the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of Virginia. Congressional Districts The equal population requirement for congressional districts is based on Article 1, Section 2 of the Constitution of the United States and is a strict standard of equality. The U.S. Supreme Court first articulated the “one-person, one-vote” principle in its ruling in Wesberry v. Sanders15, determining that the language of Article 1, Section 2 that says representatives in the United States House of Representatives are to be chosen “by the people of the several States” means that one person’s vote in a congressional district should carry the same weight as another’s. State Legislative Districts The equal population requirement for state legislative districts is based on the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States and requires “substantial equality” among legislative districts. The U.S. Supreme Court distinguished the population standards for state legislative districts from congressional districts in Reynolds v. Sims.16 Local Election Districts The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the substantially equal population requirement of the Equal Protection Clause applies to local election districts, as well.17 Article VII, Section 5 of the Constitution of Virginia also contains an equal population requirement for local election districts, requiring districts to be constituted to give “as nearly as is practicable, representation in proportion to the population of the district.” This requirement is repeated in subsection B of § 24.2-304.1 of the Code of Virginia. 15 Wesberry v. Sanders, 376 U.S. 1 (1964). 16 Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533 (1964). 17 Avery v. Midland County, 390 U.S. 474 (1968). 6 4.a.a Packet Pg. 8 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Page 20 of 54 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Substantial equality and permitted deviations. The U.S. Supreme Court has held that local election districts are subject to the substantially equal population standard, meaning the populations of local election districts do not have to be precisely equal. With this standard of substantial equality and permitted deviations, the question is, then, how much deviation is permitted and under what circumstances. Case law answering this question has evolved over the decades and, in 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court provided a clear and concise summation of where the standard stands now: States must draw congressional districts with populations as close to perfect equality as possible. But, when drawing state and local legislative districts, jurisdictions are permitted to deviate somewhat from perfect population equality to accommodate traditional districting objectives, among them, preserving the integrity of political subdivisions, maintaining communities of interest, and creating geographic compactness. When the maximum population deviation between the largest and smallest district is less than 10 percent, the Court has held, a state or local legislative map presumptively complies with the one-person, one-vote rule. Maximum deviations above 10 percent are presumptively impermissible.18 Therefore, the answer to the question is that local election districts should have populations that are substantially equal to each other, with a plus or minus five percent deviation from the ideal district population. For example, if the ideal district population is 1,000 persons, a district may have as many as 1,050 persons or as few as 950 persons in it. Local election district plans with an overall deviation of 10 percent or less are presumptively constitutional, but that does not mean the plans are immune from challenge and invalidation. The U.S. Supreme Court has specifically rejected both (i) regional protectionism, versus protection of political subdivisions, and (ii) incumbent protection when not applied in a consistent and neutral way as rational state policies when invalidating legislative district maps in Georgia that had an overall deviation of less than 10 percent.19 On the other hand, local election district plans with an overall deviation of more than 10 percent are presumed to violate the Equal Protection Clause, but that does not mean such plans will not be upheld. In these types of challenges, the local governing body has the burden of proving that there was a rational policy that was advanced by this higher deviation. 5.3. Contiguity and Compactness Article VII, Section 5 of the Constitution of Virginia requires local election districts to be composed of contiguous and compact territory. This requirement is repeated in subsection B of § 24.2-304.1 and in § 24.2-305 of the Code of Virginia. Two cases related to state legislative districts and the identical requirement that they be contiguous and compact20 provide guidance on what this requirement means for local election 18 Evenwel v. Abbott, 136 S. Ct. 1120 (2016). 19 Larios v. Cox, 542 U.S. 947 (2004). 20 See VA. CONST. Art. II, § 6. 7 4.a.a Packet Pg. 9 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Page 21 of 54 districts. In Jamerson v. Womack, the Supreme Court of Virginia held that the constitutional requirement of compactness is limited to spatial restrictions and does not mean that the districts must be compact in content as well.21 A decade later, in Wilkins v. West, the Supreme Court of Virginia found that while a voting district that contains two sections completely severed by another land mass would not satisfy the constitutional requirement of contiguity and compactness, the geography and population of Virginia necessitates that some electoral districts include water.22 Significantly, the Court held that landmasses separated by water may still meet the contiguity requirement. Compactness Measures There are several statistical methods to measure the comparative compactness of districts. These measures may produce different results and are offered by expert witnesses in litigation. The courts have not agreed on one single measure of compactness and have often relied on the appearance of a district—a visual or “eyeball” evaluation. 5.4. Race and Redistricting And then there is the thorniest of issues: race and redistricting. As stated in the introduction to this Guide, this is the most complex area of redistricting law and, as such, is frequently litigated. There are two primary bodies of law when it comes to race and redistricting, one constitutional and one statutory: the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States and the Voting Rights Act of 1965, as amended. Please note: In previous redistricting cycles, Virginia and most of its localities were subject to preclearance under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, meaning that any change to an election law, practice, or procedure, and all redistricting plans, had to be submitted for approval by the U.S. Department of Justice or a special U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. However, in 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court found that the coverage formula used to determine which specific jurisdictions were subject to the preclearance requirement was unconstitutional.23 As a result of this ruling, the Section 5 preclearance requirement is no longer enforceable. 5.4.1. Equal Protection Clause and Racial Gerrymandering The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment states, in relevant part, that no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. In the context of redistricting, this means a state cannot, without sufficient justification, separate its citizens into different voting districts on the basis of race.24 To do so would be an impermissible racial gerrymander. Prior to 1993, the concept of racial gerrymandering surfaced in cases against minority groups. In Shaw v. Reno, however, the U.S. Supreme Court held that plaintiffs could challenge a North Carolina congressional plan as an impermissible racial gerrymander under the Equal 21 Jamerson v. Womack, 423 S.E.2d 180 (Va. 1992) 22 Wilkins v. West, 571 S.E.2d 100 (Va. 2002) 23 Shelby County v. Holder, 570 U.S. 529 (2013). 24 Bethune-Hill v. Virginia State Board of Elections, 137 S. Ct. 788 (2017). 8 4.a.a Packet Pg. 10 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Page 22 of 54 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Protection Clause.25 The plaintiffs were residents of the challenged district but did not sue as members of a minority or protected class. Racial gerrymandering took on a completely new meaning. Standing To challenge a race-based redistricting plan as an impermissible racial gerrymander, an individual must have standing. This requires the plaintiff to be a resident of the challenged district. Where a plaintiff resides in a racially gerrymandered district, however, the plaintiff has been denied equal treatment because of the legislature’s reliance on racial criteria, and therefore has standing to challenge the legislature’s action.26 An individual who lives outside of a racially gerrymandered district will not have standing unless he is able to present specific supporting evidence that he personally has been subjected to a racial classification. Once standing has been established, the burden is on the plaintiff to prove a racial gerrymandering claim. Race May Be Considered The U.S. Supreme Court has recognized that race may be considered in the redistricting process. The Court has made it clear that it “never has held that race-conscious state decision making is impermissible in all circumstances,” and has recognized that a legislature will always be aware of race when it draws district lines, just as it is aware of other demographic factors, like age and economic status.27 That race was considered in and of itself does not mean an impermissible racial gerrymander has occurred. Race Cannot Predominate Proving a racial gerrymander requires proof that race was the predominant consideration in the drawing of the districts. A plaintiff pursuing a racial gerrymandering claim must show that “race was the predominant factor motivating the legislature’s decision to place a significant number of voters within or without a particular district.” To do so, the “plaintiff must prove that the legislature subordinated traditional race-neutral districting principles . . . to racial considerations.”28 In Bethune-Hill v. Virginia State Board of Elections, the U.S. Supreme Court cautioned that a plan is not required to conflict with traditional redistricting principles as a threshold issue, but it also stated that a conflict or inconsistency could be persuasive circumstantial evidence in showing racial predomination.29 25 Shaw v. Reno, 509 U.S. 630 (1993). 26 United States v. Hayes, 515 U.S. 737 (1995). 27 Shaw v. Reno, 509 U.S. 630 (1993). 28 Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama, 135 S. Ct. 1257 (2015). 29 Bethune-Hill v. Virginia State Board of Elections, 137 S. Ct. 788 (2017). 9 4.a.a Packet Pg. 11 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Page 23 of 54 In Alabama Legislative Black Caucus v. Alabama, the U.S. Supreme Court addressed how equal population requirements factor into a racial gerrymander challenge. [A]n equal population goal is not one factor among others to be weighed against the use of race to determine whether race “predominates.” Rather, it is part of the redistricting background, taken as a given, when determining whether race, or other factors, predominate in a legislator’s determination as to how equal population objectives will be met.30 Any analysis of whether race was a predominant factor must be made on a district-by-district basis, rather than the state as a whole, and should not be limited to only those parts of a district line that conflict with traditional redistricting principles. Racial predominance can be proven through circumstantial evidence of a district’s shape and demographics, direct evidence of legislative intent, or a combination of both. An informative example of direct evidence of legislative intent is highlighted in Virginia’s own Bethune-Hill, in which the U.S. Supreme Court found the state had employed a mandatory black voting-age population (BVAP) floor of 55 percent in constructing the challenged districts and that, in doing so, race had predominated over traditional districting factors.31 If a plaintiff is able to prove that race was the predominant motive of the legislature in drawing a district, a racial gerrymander has been proven, but that does not mean the district will be invalidated. Strict Scrutiny, Narrowly Tailored To Achieve a Compelling Governmental Interest If a plaintiff shows that race predominated in the drawing of a district, the plan will be subject to a strict scrutiny analysis. This means the defendant (the state) must demonstrate that the plan was narrowly tailored to achieve a compelling interest if the district is to be upheld. This can be demonstrated by a showing that the mapmakers had a “strong basis in evidence” supporting their decision to make race-based choices.32 This standard does not demand the state’s actions be “actually necessary” for statutory compliance to constitute a compelling state interest; the legislature just must have had “good reasons” to believe such use was required at the time.33 This means, the U.S. Supreme Court has said, a functional analysis of the specific district is necessary.34 The U.S. Supreme Court has previously held Virginia performed a sufficient inquiry under this standard when the state legislature’s “primary mapdrawer ‘discussed the [challenged] district with incumbents from other majority-minority districts . . . [and] considered turnout rates, the results of the recent contested primary and general elections,’ and the district’s large prison population.”35 This analysis contrasts with the North Carolina legislature’s actions during the 2011 redistricting process, where the U.S. Supreme Court determined the state did not perform a sufficient analysis because it could “point to no meaningful legislative inquiry” into 30 Alabama at 1270. 31 Bethune-Hill. 32 Alabama at 1274. 33 Id. 34 Id at 1272. 35 Abbott v. Perez, 138 S. Ct. 2305 (2018). (quoting Bethune-Hill). 10 4.a.a Packet Pg. 12 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Page 24 of 54 Virginia Division of Legislative Services whether the use of race was required to prevent liability under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act for a district.36 The Supreme Court has never held that compliance with the Voting Rights Act is a sufficiently compelling state interest to satisfy strict scrutiny. Rather, it has consistently “assumed” that compliance with Section 2 (or Section 5) of the Voting Rights Act was a compelling state interest and struck down redistricting plans on narrow tailoring grounds. 5.4.2. Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act and Minority Vote Dilution The Voting Rights Act was enacted by Congress in 1965 to give teeth to the Fifteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, which provides that the right to vote is not to be denied or abridged by the United States or any state on account of race. Unlike Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, Section 2 applies to all jurisdictions and remains in effect today. It prohibits any state or political subdivision from imposing any voting qualification, standard, practice, or procedure that results in the denial or abridgement of any U.S. citizen’s right to vote on account of race, color, or status as a member of a language minority group. In the context of redistricting, Section 2 prohibits minority vote dilution. Plaintiffs filing a Section 2 challenge do not need to prove an intent to discriminate; rather, these claims are dependent on a showing of discriminatory effects. Section 2(b) establishes the requirements for proving a Section 2 claim: A violation . . . is established if based on the totality of circumstances, it is shown that the political processes leading to nomination or election in the State or political subdivision are not equally open to participation by members of a [protected] class of citizens . . . in that its members have less opportunity than other members of the electorate to participate in the political process and to elect representatives of their choice. These requirements break down into two primary elements. First, the plaintiffs must prove that their minority group is eligible to bring a Section 2 claim. Second, the plaintiffs must prove that their votes were diluted under the totality of circumstances test. Gingles Preconditions In Thornburg v. Gingles37, the U.S. Supreme Court established three factors, or preconditions, that must be proven by plaintiffs as a threshold matter in establishing a preliminary vote dilution claim under Section 2. These preconditions establish whether the plaintiffs are members of a class of citizens protected by Section 2. 1. The racial or language minority group “is sufficiently numerous and compact to form a majority in a single-member district”; 2. The minority group is “politically cohesive,” meaning its members tend to vote similarly; and 36 Cooper v. Harris, 137 S. Ct. 1455, 1471 (2017). 37 Thornburg v. Gingles, 478 U.S. 30 (1986). 11 4.a.a Packet Pg. 13 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Page 25 of 54 3. The “majority votes sufficiently as a bloc to enable it . . . usually to defeat the minority’s preferred candidate.” The U.S. Supreme Court has offered some guidance on how these preconditions are to be applied in subsequent cases:  These preconditions for a vote dilution claim apply to single-member districts, as well as multi-member and at-large districts.38  The majority required by the first precondition means that the minority group be large enough to constitute at least half of the voting-age population in that district.39  The minority group must be “culturally compact.” Connecting two disparate communities of the same race that otherwise constitute separate communities of interest is not sufficient to satisfy the first precondition.40 Totality of Circumstances Test If plaintiffs are able to prove each of the three Gingles factors, the court then examines the “totality of the circumstances” to determine whether the minority group’s opportunity to participate in the electoral process or elect its candidates of choice have been denied or abridged. The following factors that the court will consider have evolved from several cases and a United States Senate report accompanying the 1982 amendments to Section 2:  The extent of the history of official discrimination touching on the minority group participating in the democratic process;  Racially polarized voting;  The extent to which the state or political subdivision has used unusually large election districts, majority vote requirements, anti-single-shot provisions, or other voting practices that enhance the opportunity for discrimination;  Denial of access to the candidate slating process for members of the group;  The extent to which the members of the minority group bear the effects of discrimination in areas such as education, employment, and health that hinder effective participation;  Whether political campaigns have been characterized by racial appeals;  The extent to which members of the protected class have been elected;  Whether there is a significant lack of responsiveness by elected officials to the particular needs of the group; and  Whether the policy underlying the use of the voting qualification, standard, practice, or procedure is tenuous. Racially Polarized Voting Proof of legally significant racially polarized voting is a crucial element of a Section 2 vote dilution claim. Racially polarized voting, or racial bloc voting, is found where the race of a 38 Growe v. Emison, 507 U.S. 25 (1993). 39 Bartlett v. Strickland, 556 U.S. 1 (2009). 40 League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) v. Perry, 548 U.S. 399 (2006). 12 4.a.a Packet Pg. 14 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Page 26 of 54 Virginia Division of Legislative Services candidate determines how a voter votes. Expert evidence is frequently offered to prove or disprove a history of racially polarized voting and whether the majority votes as a bloc to the detriment of the minority. Evidence on racial bloc voting patterns is directed at proving or disproving the proposition that minority voters vote for minority candidates and white voters vote for white candidates—that racial voting patterns make it more difficult for minority groups to elect the candidates of their choice. There are a number of methods used to evaluate racial bloc voting patterns, and they can be complicated. The two most commonly used statistical methods for measuring racially polarized voting are homogeneous precinct analysis and bivariate regression analysis. The U.S. Supreme Court has avoided establishing any mathematical formula for determining when racial polarization exists, instead making clear that each challenged district has to be evaluated on its own, with a number of various factors considered. Majority-Minority Districts. The U.S. Supreme Court’s Section 2 cases do not specify an exact percentage required to constitute a majority-minority district as required in a Gingles analysis. The courts conduct a fact-specific inquiry and weigh the facts concerning total population, voting age population, and other factors. No single percentage can be said to be the number needed to create a majority- minority district. The U.S. Supreme Court has rejected the proposition that a redistricting plan must “maximize” the number of majority-minority districts in Section 2 cases.41 5.5. Traditional and Emerging Districting Principles The U.S. Supreme Court first articulated the concept of “traditional districting principles” in Shaw v. Reno, when it specifically recognized contiguity and compactness as traditional principles.42 In the years that have followed, case law has recognized additional criteria as traditional districting principles. Today, there are six principles or criteria that are considered by the courts as race-neutral, traditional principles: 1. Contiguity; 2. Compactness; 3. Preservation of counties and other political subdivisions; 4. Preservation of communities of interest; 5. Preservation of cores of prior districts; and 6. Protection of incumbents. There are also a number of emerging criteria being added to the districting landscape in states across the country. Some such criteria include:  Prohibition on favoring or disfavoring an incumbent, candidate, or political party;  Prohibition on the use of partisan data; and  Competitiveness. 41 Johnson v. De Grandy, 512 U.S. 997 (1994). 42 Shaw v. Reno, 509 U.S. 630 (1993). 13 4.a.a Packet Pg. 15 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Guide to Local Redistricting for 2021 Virginia Division of Legislative Services Page 27 of 54 Additionally, the 2020 Regular Session of the General Assembly enacted legislation setting out the standards and criteria to be followed when drawing congressional and state legislative districts. While § 24.2-304.04 of the Code of Virginia does not specifically apply these criteria to local election districts, it merits review and is set out in full in Appendix A. 5.6. Balancing Competing Legal Interests The difficult reality of redistricting is that there are a number of legal requirements that are not always compatible and it is only through litigation after the fact that the flaws in how those requirements were balanced are revealed. Traditional districting principles must be considered. Race may be considered but cannot predominate in map drawing. While localities are not subject to the Voting Rights Act Section 5 preclearance this time around, Section 2 does apply. Careful and thorough consideration of multiple factors, evidence-based decision making, and comprehensive records and documentation are keys to a successful redistricting effort at the local level. 14 4.a.a Packet Pg. 16 Attachment: Extracted pages from 2021 VA Division of Legislative Services Redistricting Guide (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for 12/1/2021 www.arcbridge.com 1 Census 2020 Data Report for Pittsylvania County VA Population in 2010 63,506 Population in 2020 60,501 Prison Adjusted Population –2020 60,170 Loss 2010-2020 3,005 Loss 2010-2020 adjusted with Prison Population 3,336 Prison Population 331 4.a.b Packet Pg. 17 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of 2 2020 As-Is 2020 2020 with Prison Adjusted Population Maximum Deviation –10.78% District Count Optimum Deviation Deviation % 1 8787 8596 191 2.22% 2 8402 8596 -194 -2.26% 3 7621 8596 -975 -11.34% 4 8914 8596 318 3.70% 5 8312 8596 -284 -3.30% 6 8900 8596 304 3.54% 7 9234 8596 638 7.42% District Count Optimum Deviation Deviation % 1 8809 8643 166 1.92% 2 8342 8643 -301 -3.48% 3 8282 8643 -361 -4.18% 4 8850 8643 207 2.40% 5 8231 8643 -412 -4.77% 6 8824 8643 181 2.09% 7 9163 8643 520 6.02% Maximum Deviation –18.76% 4.a.b Packet Pg. 18 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of 3 Population by Race and Ethnicity in 2020 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 1 2 3 Population by Race and Ethnicity HISP:NHWHT:NHBLK:NHAIAN: NHASIAN:NHNHOPI:NHOTHER:NHP2MRCE: Race and Ethnicity Total Numbers Percentage HISP:1712 2.83% NHWHT:44277 73.18% NHBLK:12354 20.42% NHAIAN:93 0.15% NHASIAN:289 0.48% NHNHOPI:17 0.03% NHOTHER:128 0.21% NH Persons of 2 or more races 1631 2.70% Total 60501 100.00% 4.a.b Packet Pg. 19 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of Districts have to be adjusted –Max Deviation is > 10% (Maximum Deviation –18.76% with Prison-Adjusted Population) 4 District Count Optimum Deviation Deviation % 1 8787 8596 191 2.22% 2 8402 8596 -194 -2.26% 3 7621 8596 -975 -11.34% 4 8914 8596 318 3.70% 5 8312 8596 -284 -3.30% 6 8900 8596 304 3.54% 7 9234 8596 638 7.42% Comparison with ideal population District 7 has the most population District 3 has the least population 4.a.b Packet Pg. 20 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of Current Districts WWW.ARCBRIDGE.COM 5 Current Plan Hispanic NH White NH Black NH AIAN NH Asian NH NHOPI NH Other NH -2+ Race Total Prison- Adjusted 1 248 7242 953 17 77 8 28 236 8,809 8,787 2 152 6,609 1,299 12 18 0 9 243 8,342 8,402 3 187 3,679 4,164 7 22 2 21 200 8,282 7,621 4 206 6,872 1,448 19 33 1 28 243 8,850 8,914 5 144 6,308 1,505 16 28 1 18 211 8,231 8,312 6 466 6,199 1,843 15 38 1 6 256 8,824 8,900 7 309 7,368 1,142 7 73 4 18 242 9,163 9,234 60,501 60170 Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District % Based on Total Population Hispanic%NH White%NH Black%NH AIAN%NH Asian%NH NHOPI %NH Other% NH -2+ Race%Total 1 2.82%82.21%10.82%0.19%0.87%0.09%0.32%2.68%100.00% 2 1.82%79.23%15.57%0.14%0.22%0.00%0.11%2.91%100.00% 3 2.26%44.42%50.28%0.08%0.27%0.02%0.25%2.41%100.00% 4 2.33%77.65%16.36%0.21%0.37%0.01%0.32%2.75%100.00% 5 1.75%76.64%18.28%0.19%0.34%0.01%0.22%2.56%100.00% 6 5.28%70.25%20.89%0.17%0.43%0.01%0.07%2.90%100.00% 7 3.37%80.41%12.46%0.08%0.80%0.04%0.20%2.64%100.00% 4.a.b Packet Pg. 21 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of 6 Plan A –Maximum Deviation –3.52%Current Districts–Maximum Deviation –18.76% Proposed Plan A vs. Current Districts. Plan A has a Majority-Minority District 4.a.b Packet Pg. 22 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of Plan A Proposed Districts WWW.ARCBRIDGE.COM 7 Plan A Hispanic NH White NH Black NH AIAN NH Asian NH NHOPI NH Other NH -2+ Race Total Prison- Adjusted 1 236 7127 967 17 79 7 27 227 8,687 8,664 2 172 6,614 1,410 14 21 0 8 241 8,480 8,536 3 218 4,340 4,406 8 24 4 23 240 9,263 8,613 4 197 6,772 1,418 18 33 1 28 238 8,705 8,768 5 149 6,512 1,482 16 28 1 19 222 8,429 8,514 6 447 6,029 1,623 13 37 1 6 239 8,395 8,465 7 293 6,883 1,048 7 67 3 17 224 8,542 8,610 60,501 60170 Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District % Based on Total Population Hispanic%NH White%NH Black%NH AIAN%NH Asian%NH NHOPI %NH Other% NH -2+ Race%Total 1 2.72%82.04%11.13%0.20%0.91%0.08%0.31%2.61%100.00% 2 2.03%78.00%16.63%0.17%0.25%0.00%0.09%2.84%100.00% 3 2.35%46.85%47.57%0.09%0.26%0.04%0.25%2.59%100.00% 4 2.26%77.79%16.29%0.21%0.38%0.01%0.32%2.73%100.00% 5 1.77%77.26%17.58%0.19%0.33%0.01%0.23%2.63%100.00% 6 5.32%71.82%19.33%0.15%0.44%0.01%0.07%2.85%100.00% 7 3.43%80.58%12.27%0.08%0.78%0.04%0.20%2.62%100.00% 4.a.b Packet Pg. 23 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of 8 Plan B –Maximum Deviation –1.43%Current Districts–Maximum Deviation –18.76% Proposed Plan B vs. Current Districts 4.a.b Packet Pg. 24 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of Plan B Proposed Districts WWW.ARCBRIDGE.COM 9 Plan B Hispanic NH White NH Black NH AIAN NH Asian NH NHOPI NH Other NH -2+ Race Total Prison- Adjusted 1 224 7094 1597 18 72 9 20 210 9,244 8,531 2 165 6,608 1,491 7 26 0 6 263 8,566 8,638 3 272 5,620 2,385 15 25 1 34 232 8,584 8,596 4 184 5,908 2,044 16 41 2 23 239 8,457 8,530 5 125 6,127 1,982 17 20 2 23 221 8,517 8,596 6 454 5,973 1,816 14 36 0 6 249 8,548 8,626 7 288 6,947 1,039 6 69 3 16 217 8,585 8,653 60,501 60170 Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District % Based on Total Population Hispanic%NH White%NH Black%NH AIAN%NH Asian%NH NHOPI %NH Other% NH -2+ Race%Total 1 2.42%76.74%17.28%0.19%0.78%0.10%0.22%2.27%100.00% 2 1.93%77.14%17.41%0.08%0.30%0.00%0.07%3.07%100.00% 3 3.17%65.47%27.78%0.17%0.29%0.01%0.40%2.70%100.00% 4 2.18%69.86%24.17%0.19%0.48%0.02%0.27%2.83%100.00% 5 1.47%71.94%23.27%0.20%0.23%0.02%0.27%2.59%100.00% 6 5.31%69.88%21.24%0.16%0.42%0.00%0.07%2.91%100.00% 7 3.35%80.92%12.10%0.07%0.80%0.03%0.19%2.53%100.00% 4.a.b Packet Pg. 25 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of 10 Plan C –Maximum Deviation –1.30%Current Districts–Maximum Deviation –18.76% Proposed Plan C vs. Current Districts 4.a.b Packet Pg. 26 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of Plan C Proposed Districts WWW.ARCBRIDGE.COM 11 Plan C Hispanic NH White NH Black NH AIAN NH Asian NH NHOPI NH Other NH -2+ Race Total Prison- Adjusted 1 210 6401 1551 16 74 5 17 235 8,509 8,556 2 145 6,589 1,448 6 27 0 5 258 8,478 8,551 3 306 5,955 2,765 14 23 3 30 227 9,323 8,586 4 177 5,933 2,151 15 45 2 27 238 8,588 8,663 5 139 6,039 2,048 18 19 2 24 242 8,531 8,609 6 436 6,244 1,548 10 43 1 8 213 8,503 8,583 7 299 7,116 843 14 58 4 17 218 8,569 8,622 60,501 Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District % Based on Total Population Hispanic%NH White%NH Black%NH AIAN%NH Asian%NH NHOPI %NH Other% NH -2+ Race%Total 1 2.47%75.23%18.23%0.19%0.87%0.06%0.20%2.76%100.00% 2 1.71%77.72%17.08%0.07%0.32%0.00%0.06%3.04%100.00% 3 3.28%63.87%29.66%0.15%0.25%0.03%0.32%2.43%100.00% 4 2.06%69.08%25.05%0.17%0.52%0.02%0.31%2.77%100.00% 5 1.63%70.79%24.01%0.21%0.22%0.02%0.28%2.84%100.00% 6 5.13%73.43%18.21%0.12%0.51%0.01%0.09%2.50%100.00% 7 3.49%83.04%9.84%0.16%0.68%0.05%0.20%2.54%100.00% 4.a.b Packet Pg. 27 Attachment: Demographic Data for Current and Proposed Districts (2876 : Selection of S Boston Hwy O ld R ich m on d R dE FranklinTpkeMain StN Main StS Main StMai n StM ain S tMiltonHwyDanville ExpyD a n ville E x p y Martinsville Hwy MartinsvilleHwy W Gretna Rd E G r e t n a R d Halifax Rd C a l l a n d s R d Franklin TpkeFranklin Tpke S mith River Richmond BlvdHoll ywood RdCallands RdRinggold RdMount View RdRiver Run CirHarley LnJustin VisPeanut Rd Azalea LnMt Airy Elem CirCrabb Farm RdW in d s o r P lBell s DrLafayette Dr Oak Ridge DrGranville Ct Heffinger Ln Vandola Church Rd Curtis LnEmerson Rd Green Rock BrgTrojan LnKerns Mill RdTarpley PlWren Dr Clark St Halifax Rd Canary Ln Figure Eight RdP itt S t Miller Dr Beech Ln Oakridge CtMulberry Rd Wil son StToney StShadow Box Rd Quail RdPenhook Ln W P ro sp e c t S tFairview LnWi ndy LnRamsey RdG r a n d C tLane Rd Penny Ln Factory LnH u n dle y B ra n c h Maplewood Ct Cedar Ct Loghaven Rd Glenland Rd Re a lt y R d Chestnut Ave Owens RdSilver Creek Ct Bi g Hil l RdWells Ln P in e C ro ft C i r Go o d ma n L n Ringgold Depot Ln Crestvie w Ln Tuck RdS ta te R te 730 Kent Ln Johnson's Mill RdScott St Castle CtTransco LnGlory Dr Reservoir View TrlVandale DrPinetum RdBambi Ln Parker Pl P o p la r R d Wards Ln Cool Branch Rd Creasy St N e w to n L n M axey Ln Calvin RdDeerwood Tract CtSimpson Dr A dam s View LnN Davis DrM a r y L n Elbow RdSunset StOttawa LnLowland Dr I nc a Ln Hackberry RdWinston CirAlta StA d a m s L n Mill RdJacob PlOrchard DrForest CtCamney RdVictoria L n P i e r c e C tD an ie l Rd Corner RdDiscovery RdHazel LnSharon WayMeadowlark RdDodson LnMaybrook AveHowerton LnSwedwood DrM a y a R d W hitefall Rd Kadesh Ct Callahan Hill Rd Hearp Ln O wl L n A p ostolic Dr Keesee Rd Smith RdWalker Dr C ed ar C rest L nEcho LnLakeridge DrPleasant Dr Roach-Moore Ln S h e ld o n C tLake Point DrMiller LnSta t e R t e 7 4 3 Nalls St Banleys St Old Mayfield Rd Zebr a RdSylvan RdR u shin g B ran c h R d F a w n W a y Pudding Creek Rd B e lle O a k C tChatham Hall Ci rP rin c e to n D rOak Grove Dr S p a r t a n C t Early RdCa mb u ri d e s D rMagnolia Acres RdSl o w Wa t e r C t Wilkes Dr Sleeper LnD e erfield L n O ld O a k T rlCenter St M as h Bra n ch L n Greentree RdGobbler Ln E Sunset Dr W arehouse RdWoodbriar Ln E agle L nWalker Ridge Rd Harper Ln Priv Dr Or Prop Saunders Shop RdApplewood DrCross Creek LnJohnson Oakes RdD e erford Dr Harrier Ln Sassens Rdg Serenity LnN ine L ots Rd Pineview RdPeakland RdGardner St Exd Pear Tree Pl Page Rd Hundred Acre RdJessies LnLewis RdShields Rd S pa rt a n Ln Douglas DrHyler Cir Scruggsway Ter Holt St Johnson Farm RdPritchett Farm R d Pineview DrLewis Ln Ramp Rd Red Oak Rd Bu nker LnFriendship RdBarbour RdFoxfire Rd Reese DrTubbs L n Late RdOleander DrFalcon View DrLion Ln Gradual Grade Rd P ic k er L n Katie Hill RdDrury Ln Sugartree LnTardys CtFox Hunt Trl Brooks Ln Farm Rd Fall Creek Dr Fox TrlG ra n d v ie w F a r m R d Lakeview Forest Dr Old Mountain Rd Perdue DrAirport RdFairoaks RdStrawberry RdStallion Rd S p a n g le r D rS ton e M oun tain R dM a is o n D rOak Ridge Farm s Rd Ivy Cliff Rd T e rry L n Bowater DrW h iteh e a d S tWri gh t L nEasley Brown RdFay Lee Dr Dove Rd C a s e y C ir Yates Farm RdDaniel Ct Bennie DrWalnut Hill Rd F in g e r la k e R d Atlantic Timber Ln Railroad Ln G o o d vie w R d Moore Dairy Farm RdConcord Rd,N P o in t e L n Woodhaven DrF a i r wa y LnRidgeview R dOakland DrDogwood DrJefferson DrHyler Farm Ln J o s h R d Redd Ln Windsor TrlKristy Ln Brumfield Ct Constellation DrMulberry Trailer Park Lemon Ln Alle n Cree k R dIrby CirSkyline Girls RdCarter Dr Pinetum Ln River RdRawless Dr Homeport LnMarilla LnTriple Creek Farm RdBonny AveHorseshoe Rd Walnut RdLearner Ln White Dr Rocksprings LnClay Branch Rd Sycamore Creek Rd Treeline Rd T urn er L n Rorer St B ro w ning Ln Riverbend RdWi n d y Hill Ct Manna Hill Rd Four Pond Ter Rison St Newby LnSaddle Rd Hollys RdO w l C tBeckham CtAngie RdKeatts LnParker Rd WB rid le P a th T rlG osney Farm Rd Hemlock Dr O ld C a b in T r lMotleyEnglishs DrBent Cr eek RdInman DrLocust LnB a rke r Fa r m Rd H e n ry s M ill L n Collie TerLong CirC r a d d o c k L n Alle n D r Rosebud CtMorgan Ln Harpers Dairy RdJay Bird LnLu m pkin View Dr Hardy Creek LnIndustrial DrPear Tree RdCreeksview Ln Anderson PinesCar efr e e LnKeesee LnSquirrel RdTributary Rd Cheroke Ln Wil liam DrHunts Town Rd Oriole LnOak Crest RdCedar LnCollie StVirginia Ln Fox Berry Ln C e d ar Rid g e R d R Rou t e 7 2 8 R ob i n R i dg e Ct Bob Neal LnHamilton Tract LnLakeside Dr Chestnut Ridge LnCreek Bottom RdFalls LnR u b y L n Suburban DrBowe St Sweetgum LnSonshine DrTaylor Rd H o n e y w o o d Rd Wa y n e R o ber t s o n R d Wal t er Be ave rs P l Steam Way Brittany Rd Royale Dr Pine StK n o ttin g ha m W ayOak Ridge LnWarbler Ln Hill and Dale Farm R d B r u s h A r b o r C tFon t ai ne Rd Bat t er man RdStaunton River LndgCluster Pines Rd P e n in s u la P l Blue Jay LnOlde Hunting TrlReed Creek CtSl a u g h t e r A v e Gopher RdSwanson Ave L o n e s o m e P o n d R d Sidi ng Ci rMagnolia LnMeadows Farm RdStill Spring Dr Collins Farm RdUnicorn Dr Tow er Ln Sweden Fork Creek LnPvt Industrial RdDoe LnGolden LnJackson Hts Mallard Lake Dr Haymes RdHi gh Vi ew LnChickadee Rd Johns Run C reek R dWallace Ln Dav i s Fa r m RdPonderosa Dr L y n s k e y F a r m R d Gilbert RdCheyenne LnWi tcher RdCovington DrMacy Herndon Ln Tucks Cemetery RdAppletree RdHaymes LnFar m RdWin d y A cre s Trl Garden Dr Hudson Cir Rodgers RdWi l e s R d D airy L n Eskew Ln Hill Crest LnSharon Ln Sig n et R d Roy Ford Rd Cl ay Rd J a y B i r d H i l l R d Three Barn Rd R Route 725Rosewood CtIris LnElderberry LnGiles Ln Chestnut Ln Pi t chf or k RdLogan Ln Mohawk RdDr Mease Dr Cooksburg RdToshes RdBeach Hollow RdF E Keatts Ln Cascade Baptist Rd Buck Hill Rd Mountain Top DrHamilton Tract Rd B uckhorn D rDrawbridge RdMerricks Cv D arrell L n G u n n L nSimpson LnMeadowridge CtS Jamer son RdWalk Ln Rowland Dr M o u n t Z ion C h u rch R dW Withers Rd B e a rs k in S u b sta tio n R d W oodlawn HtsSilv er F o x R d J u n ior O aks R dCocke Ln Rosebud Rd O ake s & Sta nfiel d R d Big Sky Rd Hunting Ridge RdRicky Van Shelton Dr Gloria Ln Bennett St R is o n S t E x d Samuel Rd Lynn StL est er LnCundiff Ln Dewb e rr y R d Church LnS tra w b e rry C re e l L n K e s w ic k D r Mabe DrD a v is D rGrubb Rd Sugartree Manor Dr W H igh t ower R d Indian Trail RdRe es e Lo op RdDogwood Ln H u n te rs T rlBlack Bird Pl N o r t h s i d e D r Ferrell LnWorley Ct Faith Cove RdCompton RdFryingpan Ln C o u n t r y D r B a ile s s D r McNichols LnSt at on DrKyle RdL o n g Br a n c h Wa yPigg River RdBachelor Hall Ln D eerfie ld D rAdams Trl Centerville Rd L a k e sid e R d Sweden Fall s LnA lp in e Ln Junior Dodson Rd May Hardy Rd Stone Creek RdBloxsom RdPeach StW ashburn DrCamellia Ln Fairmont Rd H en ry Dr Basel RdBeechnut Rd Military DrThroughway Rd Wyatt DrLaurel Woods DrDogpatch LnGemstone LnWorley Ln Fla min g o R d School Rd Luster Rd L an d ru m R d Sam Adams Rd W Hurt Rd G e or g e R d Poplar TrceRiver Run Rd L o n g B ra n c h D r B o w l D r Spl endor s Gat e RdEagle Springs Rd B e a g le R d L a n ie r L n H ylto n L n River Ridge Ln E d dies L n N F o r k Dr Coffey St Longview Rd Easy Run RdBlankenship Rd M a p le D r Jasper Ln Brown RdApple LnCherrywood RdRiver Ridge DrCountryside CtBelair RdSkylock RdPittsville CirC a t aw b a D r Carson Lester Ln Tobacco RdS Briar Mountain Rd Two Pond Rd Sanctuary Bay DrRidge Rd Peacock Acres TrlRi dgeway DrStaunton River PlSwallow Rd Henry St H icko ry F o rest R d Princeton R dToshes Rd Stateline Bridge Rd Joe Carter Rd Brookside Ct Whitetail AveForestroad DrAdkins LnRay Mi ll RdMe a d d o c k L n Thompson RdHall Farmer RdJones Mil l RdN e w H o p e R d Wet Sleeve Creek Rd Hubbard RdHigh Meadow Cir S p rin g tr e e R d Al be c k Dr Bean Land RdB lacksmith Rd C e d a r S p r in g R d R o a r in g F o rk L a k e R d Meadow Brook Cir R etre at D r Sanctuary RdOakland DrWhitehorn Rd Vest RdMartin Rd C reeks B ank Rd Chaneys Stor e RdC e d a r Ga t e s Lo o p R d Cross Creek RdCompton DrDaniel LnJeanette DrPayne St W W itt RdRipley Dr Keatts Rd Grandad LnLog Cabin RdG e n tle P a s tu re R d Petty LnP rim itiv e B a p tis t R d W Rockwood Dr Hollyville Dr Jamerson Rd NPritchett LnWoodlawn Academy RdLong Short Rd Crossbow Dr Georges LnAl ber t Edmonds Dr Peaceful Ln Blair LnHerman Farmer RdWal lace WayS y c a m o re C ir Kendall Rd Henrys Mill Ct Horseshoe Dr Stowe Ln Logging RdCharming RdHankins LnHeron Poi nt e Dr Sunshine Acres Gretna Rd F o ster R d Winterhaven TrlSam Haley RdPonderosa Rd C ollie L n Cherokee Ln Oakwood DrM ockingbird Rd K elle y s D r D u n c a n D r Leesville Lake DrClarks Mill RdCoy Creek LnWoodview RdParker RdChippewa LnShotgun R dRocky Knoll LnMarson RdD ee p R u n R d Deerwood DrRed Ha wk L nHoneybee Rd L iv esto ck RdWoodview DrColony Rd Chestnut Ridge RdWhit e Oak Mou nt ai n DrRed Hill RdMount Hermon Cir High Point Rd Cedar Rd Chan e ys St or e RdG l e n n B ro w n R d C ava li e r RdChesapeake Dr S R iver R d Mountain View Shores Dr Floyd Smith Rd D elta D rM a n gru m s R dD e er H a v e n D r Buford RdPlaycation Retreat Cir Al mon d RdArnn LnNeal Davis RdJackson Ln Camp Branch Rd McNeely LnCross St i tch RdGammon Lake Rd E S to re L n Childress RdOttawa DrOwen RdAstin LnCemetery Rd O ld C a b in R d Robertson LnLakevie w Dr B e rry R d H e r n d o n L n Orange RdIona Rd Rigney Cir Laurel Ln Vance Hill Rd Tight Squeeze Rd Sandy Bottom Rd Peytonsburg R d Adams Farm Ln H ed ge R d Lee Ave Hu nt e r Rd Keens RdHighwayview RdR oach M e m orial Dr Liberty Rd Foxridge Rd Cherrystone RdMar t i n RdAvendale RdValley Rd S h e llh o r s e R dGordon RdB u r n e tt H o o d R d S Flint Hill Rd Raven Hollow Rd Coxs Store Rd B Jones RdDeer Track Farm RdHundley DrW S pencer R d Kendrick Rd Moores DrPinecroft RdRichardson LnHom estead TrlCedar Forest Rd Deercrest LnBobby Ln Dr Edward Williams Rd L e f t w ich S t Happy Ln Mic h a u x R d Cardwell LnMelon Rd Hutcherson Rd C h e stn ut L e v el L nDaisy Payne LnBassett Ln Owl Rd Jasper Wood Rd P a n n ell Dr Owl Dr Easley Rd Little Creek RdE W i tt R d Bennett DrF C Beverly RdM o s c h le r D rMaurakis RdFrancis Rd Millsville LnHither LnGalveston RdHarper RdTurkeycock Mountain Rd Jacobs RdB uck Track R d Star L a n d D r Al derso n Rd O liv e rs LnGammon s L a k e R d Azalea Dr W Maple Dr Oliver Rd N Briar Mountain RdHoney Rd Emery Rd Carter Lodge Rd Logwood AveBrownville Heights LnMerc u ry R d Magnolia RdHines Chapel RdGentlemans Ridge Rd Irby Rd Loblolly Dr Garrison Rdg Buck Horne RdM eado w view D rMill Creek RdRockcreek RdWatlington RdJohnson Rd Moses Mill Rd G andy RdSpaniel Rd Mitchell Rd M il l s t r ea m D rDaltons Farm LnFriendly Dr County Rd Dry Bridge RdColes RdRiceville Ct Maple Springs Dr La wless Creek R dTomahawk Mill RdShawnee RdColeman RdFall Creek RdFarmers Mountain Rd Wynell Dr Tightsqueeze Rd B a rn R d W F o rk R dC o u r t R d Plantation DrProspect RdOld Quarry RdDavid Giles LnRainbow LnT o ma h a w k Creek R d St one RdMill B r a n c h R d M il a m R d L o o mfi x e r L a k e Rd Old Hickory LnDaybreak TerG ravel Hill R dGreen Bay Rd Doctor Milams Rd Spruse Rd Ril ey Farm RdWalnut Creek RdTunstall High RdSmith Rd Flat Top Cove RdCooper RdClover Rd Barker RdSportsman Rd Slayton RdBen A nnie RdAndre w Rd Mountain LnDavis Rd Player RdWaller LnWeller LnLotus DrBelmort Dr Waller Rd Ferry Rd Bair Branch RdWi Powell RdEd Hardy Rd Jen nin gs D rLeaksville Junction RdE Hightower Rd Pounds RdElm Rd Clearview DrN Maple Rd Parrish Rd S ilv e r C re ek R dMac RdVictoria RdAstro Dr Dairy Vi ew RdTender LnBrandon Rd Kentuck Church Rd Hill Creek RdArmstrong RdCountry Cl ub RdOak Grove RdHubbard RdTransco Rd Motley Rd Yeatts Store Rd Locust Dr Hunting Hills RdW Giles RdBurke RdDarby RdFairview N Whit e Oa k C ir Hermosa Rd Pine Lake Rd Beverly Heights RdDouble Bridge Rd Lark Dr Tates Mill RdC a m p v ie w R d H o me ste a d R d Ridgecrest DrFo r d RdMountain Hill RdStarkey RdOld Red Eye Rd Hawkins RdMcC ormick Rd Silas Dodd Ln A fto n R d B ru mfield R d Cane Creek PkwyAnderson Rd Terry RdRo s e St Wyatts RdCherrystone Lake Rd Walkers Well RdMaysville Rd M c D a n i e l R d River Ridge Rd Ho pewe ll RdRandol ph Dr S y c a more R d Riddle Rd Mot l eys Mi ll RdMotleys Rd S u n s e t D r Fruitridge Dr Columbus Rd M a rin a D rTwin Arch DrConcord RdCrane RdSandy Creek Rd C r o w n R d Maple RdSpring Buck CirSugar Barbour Rd G r e e n F a rm R d Sandy Rd Mountain Run RdCott o n Pa t c h RdMill Run RdHodnetts RdSandy River RdGrit Rd Pickaway RdW ilk e rs o n R d Dabney House RdStone Mill RdOwens Mill Rd B e n n e tt C irBrushy Mountain RdHut son RdCava lr y Rd Wade Rd Cody RdEa so me Rd Double Creek RdInman RdSandy Creek Church Rd Cobbs Knob RdLo op R d Laurel Grove Rd Moorefield Bridge RdHillside RdPeach Orchard Rd Fe r g uson R d Countryside Dr Ringgold Depot Rd H ickory RdSprin g Rd Ivory Branch Rd Allan Creek RdLester RdMi dway RdBoxwood Rd Malmaison Rd Abbott Pl Robinhood Rd B e rry v ille R d Izaak Walton RdGraves Bridge RdHunters LnRed Rd H in e s v ille R d Weatherford DrN Flint Hill Rd Music St Vandola DrGallows Rd W Sunrise DrMill Creek Rd Mountain RdCedar Hill RdS to n y M ill S c h o o l R d Upper Mountain RdSummerset Rd NRidgeway RdLaniers Mill RdSailors Creek RdHa r bo r Dr Paisley RdWhite Ridge RdSnowberry RdMountain DrRobertson RdGap Rd Hodnetts Mill Rd Piney Grove Rd Hickeys Rd Mapleton Dr Bearskin Rd W h ite Fall R d Water Oak Rd T o m F o r k R d Sheva Rd Snakepath RdN M eado w s R dTelegraph RdColeman Mountain RdReeves Mill Rd K e e lin g D r Taylors Mill R d Church Rd Pleasant Gap DrHu n t in gto n T r l Cedar Rd Triangle School Rd R & L S m ith D rM o s c o R d Elkh o rn Rd Stony Mill RdZion Rd Fairview Rd B roo ksid e R dMarion RdR o c k s prin g s R d Bu r t on La ke Rd Wards RdScott Jacobs Memorial DrMartin DrGl envi ew Dr Weal Rd J a s m in e R d Sugartree Church Rd Banister RdRockford School Rd C o o k s b urg R d Green Pond RdGlade RdUnion Hall School RdDerby Rd Bibee RdDry Fork Rd Game Reserve Rd Birch Creek RdKerns Church RdStillmeadow RdFarmers RdJohnson Mill RdRinggold Church Rd Oak Hill RdPayneton Rd M ead o w s R d S M e a d o w s R d Wyatt Farm Rd Tucker RdYorkshire DrGolf Club RdHarmony RdEd munds Rd Mount Tabor RdOld Mine Rd Anderson Mill Rd Henrys Mill Rd Ir i s h R d Pocket Rd Piney R dShula Dr Dodson Rd W his p erin g Pin e s R d R ic e v ille R d Strader RdRoark Mill Rd Ca scade Mill RdJ ava R dSmith Mountain Rd Anderson Mill RdOxford RdLevel Run Rd Whitmell School Rd Markham Rd Pittsville Rd Dews RdM o ons RdSago Rd O ld H w y 2 9 Brights Rd Re nan R d Sl at esvi l l e RdMedical Center Rd B erry H ill R dCascade RdMusevill e RdRockford School RdStraightstone RdClimax RdDeer View Rd Grassland Dr B lu e R id g e D rS pring G arden RdChalk Level RdKentuck RdMount Cross Rd ¬«62 ¬«57 ¬«57 ¬«360 ¬«57 ¬«57 ¬«41 ¬«41 ¬«40 ¬«40 ¬«40 £¤58 £¤58 £¤29 £¤29 £¤29 £¤29 £¤360 £¤58 Chatham Gretna Hurt Blairs Motley MountHermon Sources: Esri, HERE, Garmin, USGS, Intermap, INCREMENT P, NRCan, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong), Esri Korea, Esri (Thailand), NGCC, (c) OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community Pittsylvania County Commission Districts - Plan A Minor Roads Secondary Roads Primary Roads Current Districts Places Districts 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 0 2 4 6 81Miles . 4.a.c Packet Pg. 28 Attachment: Plan A (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at Board's December Busines) S mith River Richmond BlvdHoll ywood RdCallands RdRinggold RdMount View RdRiver Run CirHarley LnJustin VisPeanut Rd Azalea LnMt Airy Elem CirCrabb Farm RdW in d s o r P lBell s DrLafayette Dr Oak Ridge DrGranville Ct Heffinger Ln Vandola Church Rd Curtis LnEmerson Rd Green Rock BrgTrojan LnKerns Mill RdTarpley PlWren Dr Clark St Halifax Rd Canary Ln Figure Eight RdP itt S t Miller Dr Beech Ln Oakridge CtMulberry Rd Wil son StToney StShadow Box Rd Quail RdPenhook Ln W P ro sp e c t S tFairview LnWi ndy LnRamsey RdG r a n d C tLane Rd Penny Ln Factory LnH u n dle y B ra n c h Maplewood Ct Cedar Ct Loghaven Rd Glenland Rd Re a lt y R d Chestnut Ave Owens RdSilver Creek Ct Bi g Hil l RdWells Ln P in e C ro ft C i r Go o d ma n L n Ringgold Depot Ln Crestvie w Ln Tuck RdS ta te R te 730 Kent Ln Johnson's Mill RdScott St Castle CtTransco LnGlory Dr Reservoir View TrlVandale DrPinetum RdBambi Ln Parker Pl P o p la r R d Wards Ln Cool Branch Rd Creasy St N e w to n L n M axey Ln Calvin RdDeerwood Tract CtSimpson Dr A dam s View LnN Davis DrM a r y L n Elbow RdSunset StOttawa LnLowland Dr I nc a Ln Hackberry RdWinston CirAlta StA d a m s L n Mill RdJacob PlOrchard DrForest CtCamney RdVictoria L n P i e r c e C tD an ie l Rd Corner RdDiscovery RdHazel LnSharon WayMeadowlark RdDodson LnMaybrook AveHowerton LnSwedwood DrM a y a R d W hitefall Rd Kadesh Ct Callahan Hill Rd Hearp Ln O wl L n A p ostolic Dr Keesee Rd Smith RdWalker Dr C ed ar C rest L nEcho LnLakeridge DrPleasant Dr Roach-Moore Ln S h e ld o n C tLake Point DrMiller LnSta t e R t e 7 4 3 Nalls St Banleys St Old Mayfield Rd Zebr a RdSylvan RdR u shin g B ran c h R d F a w n W a y Pudding Creek Rd B e lle O a k C tChatham Hall Ci rP rin c e to n D rOak Grove Dr S p a r t a n C t Early RdCa mb u ri d e s D rMagnolia Acres RdSl o w Wa t e r C t Wilkes Dr Sleeper LnD e erfield L n O ld O a k T rlCenter St M as h Bra n ch L n Greentree RdGobbler Ln E Sunset Dr W arehouse RdWoodbriar Ln E agle L nWalker Ridge Rd Harper Ln Priv Dr Or Prop Saunders Shop RdApplewood DrCross Creek LnJohnson Oakes RdD e erford Dr Harrier Ln Sassens Rdg Serenity LnN ine L ots Rd Pineview RdPeakland RdGardner St Exd Pear Tree Pl Page Rd Hundred Acre RdJessies LnLewis RdShields Rd S pa rt a n Ln Douglas DrHyler Cir Scruggsway Ter Holt St Johnson Farm RdPritchett Farm R d Pineview DrLewis Ln Ramp Rd Red Oak Rd Bu nker LnFriendship RdBarbour RdFoxfire Rd Reese DrTubbs L n Late RdOleander DrFalcon View DrLion Ln Gradual Grade Rd P ic k er L n Katie Hill RdDrury Ln Sugartree LnTardys CtFox Hunt Trl Brooks Ln Farm Rd Fall Creek Dr Fox TrlG ra n d v ie w F a r m R d Lakeview Forest Dr Old Mountain Rd Perdue DrAirport RdFairoaks RdStrawberry RdStallion Rd S p a n g le r D rS ton e M oun tain R dM a is o n D rOak Ridge Farm s Rd Ivy Cliff Rd T e rry L n Bowater DrW h iteh e a d S tWri gh t L nEasley Brown RdFay Lee Dr Dove Rd C a s e y C ir Yates Farm RdDaniel Ct Bennie DrWalnut Hill Rd F in g e r la k e R d Atlantic Timber Ln Railroad Ln G o o d vie w R d Moore Dairy Farm RdConcord Rd,N P o in t e L n Woodhaven DrF a i r wa y LnRidgeview R dOakland DrDogwood DrJefferson DrHyler Farm Ln J o s h R d Redd Ln Windsor TrlKristy Ln Brumfield Ct Constellation DrMulberry Trailer Park Lemon Ln Alle n Cree k R dIrby CirSkyline Girls RdCarter Dr Pinetum Ln River RdRawless Dr Homeport LnMarilla LnTriple Creek Farm RdBonny AveHorseshoe Rd Walnut RdLearner Ln White Dr Rocksprings LnClay Branch Rd Sycamore Creek Rd Treeline Rd T urn er L n Rorer St B ro w ning Ln Riverbend RdWi n d y Hill Ct Manna Hill Rd Four Pond Ter Rison St Newby LnSaddle Rd Hollys RdO w l C tBeckham CtAngie RdKeatts LnParker Rd WB rid le P a th T rlG osney Farm Rd Hemlock Dr O ld C a b in T r lMotleyEnglishs DrBent Cr eek RdInman DrLocust LnB a rke r Fa r m Rd H e n ry s M ill L n Collie TerLong CirC r a d d o c k L n Alle n D r Rosebud CtMorgan Ln Harpers Dairy RdJay Bird LnLu m pkin View Dr Hardy Creek LnIndustrial DrPear Tree RdCreeksview Ln Anderson PinesCar efr e e LnKeesee LnSquirrel RdTributary Rd Cheroke Ln Wil liam DrHunts Town Rd Oriole LnOak Crest RdCedar LnCollie StVirginia Ln Fox Berry Ln C e d ar Rid g e R d R Rou t e 7 2 8 R ob i n R i dg e Ct Bob Neal LnHamilton Tract LnLakeside Dr Chestnut Ridge LnCreek Bottom RdFalls LnR u b y L n Suburban DrBowe St Sweetgum LnSonshine DrTaylor Rd H o n e y w o o d Rd Wa y n e R o ber t s o n R d Wal t er Be ave rs P l Steam Way Brittany Rd Royale Dr Pine StK n o ttin g ha m W ayOak Ridge LnWarbler Ln Hill and Dale Farm R d B r u s h A r b o r C tFon t ai ne Rd Bat t er man RdStaunton River LndgCluster Pines Rd P e n in s u la P l Blue Jay LnOlde Hunting TrlReed Creek CtSl a u g h t e r A v e Gopher RdSwanson Ave L o n e s o m e P o n d R d Sidi ng Ci rMagnolia LnMeadows Farm RdStill Spring Dr Collins Farm RdUnicorn Dr Tow er Ln Sweden Fork Creek LnPvt Industrial RdDoe LnGolden LnJackson Hts Mallard Lake Dr Haymes RdHi gh Vi ew LnChickadee Rd Johns Run C reek R dWallace Ln Dav i s Fa r m RdPonderosa Dr L y n s k e y F a r m R d Gilbert RdCheyenne LnWi tcher RdCovington DrMacy Herndon Ln Tucks Cemetery RdAppletree RdHaymes LnFar m RdWin d y A cre s Trl Garden Dr Hudson Cir Rodgers RdWi l e s R d D airy L n Eskew Ln Hill Crest LnSharon Ln Sig n et R d Roy Ford Rd Cl ay Rd J a y B i r d H i l l R d Three Barn Rd R Route 725Rosewood CtIris LnElderberry LnGiles Ln Chestnut Ln Pi t chf or k RdLogan Ln Mohawk RdDr Mease Dr Cooksburg RdToshes RdBeach Hollow RdF E Keatts Ln Cascade Baptist Rd Buck Hill Rd Mountain Top DrHamilton Tract Rd B uckhorn D rDrawbridge RdMerricks Cv D arrell L n G u n n L nSimpson LnMeadowridge CtS Jamer son RdWalk Ln Rowland Dr M o u n t Z ion C h u rch R dW Withers Rd B e a rs k in S u b sta tio n R d W oodlawn HtsSilv er F o x R d J u n ior O aks R dCocke Ln Rosebud Rd O ake s & Sta nfiel d R d Big Sky Rd Hunting Ridge RdRicky Van Shelton Dr Gloria Ln Bennett St R is o n S t E x d Samuel Rd Lynn StL est er LnCundiff Ln Dewb e rr y R d Church LnS tra w b e rry C re e l L n K e s w ic k D r Mabe DrD a v is D rGrubb Rd Sugartree Manor Dr W H igh t ower R d Indian Trail RdRe es e Lo op RdDogwood Ln H u n te rs T rlBlack Bird Pl N o r t h s i d e D r Ferrell LnWorley Ct Faith Cove RdCompton RdFryingpan Ln C o u n t r y D r B a ile s s D r McNichols LnSt at on DrKyle RdL o n g Br a n c h Wa yPigg River RdBachelor Hall Ln D eerfie ld D rAdams Trl Centerville Rd L a k e sid e R d Sweden Fall s LnA lp in e Ln Junior Dodson Rd May Hardy Rd Stone Creek RdBloxsom RdPeach StW ashburn DrCamellia Ln Fairmont Rd H en ry Dr Basel RdBeechnut Rd Military DrThroughway Rd Wyatt DrLaurel Woods DrDogpatch LnGemstone LnWorley Ln Fla min g o R d School Rd Luster Rd L an d ru m R d Sam Adams Rd W Hurt Rd G e or g e R d Poplar TrceRiver Run Rd L o n g B ra n c h D r B o w l D r Spl endor s Gat e RdEagle Springs Rd B e a g le R d L a n ie r L n H ylto n L n River Ridge Ln E d dies L n N F o r k Dr Coffey St Longview Rd Easy Run RdBlankenship Rd M a p le D r Jasper Ln Brown RdApple LnCherrywood RdRiver Ridge DrCountryside CtBelair RdSkylock RdPittsville CirC a t aw b a D r Carson Lester Ln Tobacco RdS Briar Mountain Rd Two Pond Rd Sanctuary Bay DrRidge Rd Peacock Acres TrlRi dgeway DrStaunton River PlSwallow Rd Henry St H icko ry F o rest R d Princeton R dToshes Rd Stateline Bridge Rd Joe Carter Rd Brookside Ct Whitetail AveForestroad DrAdkins LnRay Mi ll RdMe a d d o c k L n Thompson RdHall Farmer RdJones Mil l RdN e w H o p e R d Wet Sleeve Creek Rd Hubbard RdHigh Meadow Cir S p rin g tr e e R d Al be c k Dr Bean Land RdB lacksmith Rd C e d a r S p r in g R d R o a r in g F o rk L a k e R d Meadow Brook Cir R etre at D r Sanctuary RdOakland DrWhitehorn Rd Vest RdMartin Rd C reeks B ank Rd Chaneys Stor e RdC e d a r Ga t e s Lo o p R d Cross Creek RdCompton DrDaniel LnJeanette DrPayne St W W itt RdRipley Dr Keatts Rd Grandad LnLog Cabin RdG e n tle P a s tu re R d Petty LnP rim itiv e B a p tis t R d W Rockwood Dr Hollyville Dr Jamerson Rd NPritchett LnWoodlawn Academy RdLong Short Rd Crossbow Dr Georges LnAl ber t Edmonds Dr Peaceful Ln Blair LnHerman Farmer RdWal lace WayS y c a m o re C ir Kendall Rd Henrys Mill Ct Horseshoe Dr Stowe Ln Logging RdCharming RdHankins LnHeron Poi nt e Dr Sunshine Acres Gretna Rd F o ster R d Winterhaven TrlSam Haley RdPonderosa Rd C ollie L n Cherokee Ln Oakwood DrM ockingbird Rd K elle y s D r D u n c a n D r Leesville Lake DrClarks Mill RdCoy Creek LnWoodview RdParker RdChippewa LnShotgun R dRocky Knoll LnMarson RdD ee p R u n R d Deerwood DrRed Ha wk L nHoneybee Rd L iv esto ck RdWoodview DrColony Rd Chestnut Ridge RdWhit e Oak Mou nt ai n DrRed Hill RdMount Hermon Cir High Point Rd Cedar Rd Chan e ys St or e RdG l e n n B ro w n R d C ava li e r RdChesapeake Dr S R iver R d Mountain View Shores Dr Floyd Smith Rd D elta D rM a n gru m s R dD e er H a v e n D r Buford RdPlaycation Retreat Cir Al mon d RdArnn LnNeal Davis RdJackson Ln Camp Branch Rd McNeely LnCross St i tch RdGammon Lake Rd E S to re L n Childress RdOttawa DrOwen RdAstin LnCemetery Rd O ld C a b in R d Robertson LnLakevie w Dr B e rry R d H e r n d o n L n Orange RdIona Rd Rigney Cir Laurel Ln Vance Hill Rd Tight Squeeze Rd Sandy Bottom Rd Peytonsburg R d Adams Farm Ln H ed ge R d Lee Ave Hu nt e r Rd Keens RdHighwayview RdR oach M e m orial Dr Liberty Rd Foxridge Rd Cherrystone RdMar t i n RdAvendale RdValley Rd S h e llh o r s e R dGordon RdB u r n e tt H o o d R d S Flint Hill Rd Raven Hollow Rd Coxs Store Rd B Jones RdDeer Track Farm RdHundley DrW S pencer R d Kendrick Rd Moores DrPinecroft RdRichardson LnHom estead TrlCedar Forest Rd Deercrest LnBobby Ln Dr Edward Williams Rd L e f t w ich S t Happy Ln Mic h a u x R d Cardwell LnMelon Rd Hutcherson Rd C h e stn ut L e v el L nDaisy Payne LnBassett Ln Owl Rd Jasper Wood Rd P a n n ell Dr Owl Dr Easley Rd Little Creek RdE W i tt R d Bennett DrF C Beverly RdM o s c h le r D rMaurakis RdFrancis Rd Millsville LnHither LnGalveston RdHarper RdTurkeycock Mountain Rd Jacobs RdB uck Track R d Star L a n d D r Al derso n Rd O liv e rs LnGammon s L a k e R d Azalea Dr W Maple Dr Oliver Rd N Briar Mountain RdHoney Rd Emery Rd Carter Lodge Rd Logwood AveBrownville Heights LnMerc u ry R d Magnolia RdHines Chapel RdGentlemans Ridge Rd Irby Rd Loblolly Dr Garrison Rdg Buck Horne RdM eado w view D rMill Creek RdRockcreek RdWatlington RdJohnson Rd Moses Mill Rd G andy RdSpaniel Rd Mitchell Rd M il l s t r ea m D rDaltons Farm LnFriendly Dr County Rd Dry Bridge RdColes RdRiceville Ct Maple Springs Dr La wless Creek R dTomahawk Mill RdShawnee RdColeman RdFall Creek RdFarmers Mountain Rd Wynell Dr Tightsqueeze Rd B a rn R d W F o rk R dC o u r t R d Plantation DrProspect RdOld Quarry RdDavid Giles LnRainbow LnT o ma h a w k Creek R d St one RdMill B r a n c h R d M il a m R d L o o mfi x e r L a k e Rd Old Hickory LnDaybreak TerG ravel Hill R dGreen Bay Rd Doctor Milams Rd Spruse Rd Ril ey Farm RdWalnut Creek RdTunstall High RdSmith Rd Flat Top Cove RdCooper RdClover Rd Barker RdSportsman Rd Slayton RdBen A nnie RdAndre w Rd Mountain LnDavis Rd Player RdWaller LnWeller LnLotus DrBelmort Dr Waller Rd Ferry Rd Bair Branch RdWi Powell RdEd Hardy Rd Jen nin gs D rLeaksville Junction RdE Hightower Rd Pounds RdElm Rd Clearview DrN Maple Rd Parrish Rd S ilv e r C re ek R dMac RdVictoria RdAstro Dr Dairy Vi ew RdTender LnBrandon Rd Kentuck Church Rd Hill Creek RdArmstrong RdCountry Cl ub RdOak Grove RdHubbard RdTransco Rd Motley Rd Yeatts Store Rd Locust Dr Hunting Hills RdW Giles RdBurke RdDarby RdFairview N Whit e Oa k C ir Hermosa Rd Pine Lake Rd Beverly Heights RdDouble Bridge Rd Lark Dr Tates Mill RdC a m p v ie w R d H o me ste a d R d Ridgecrest DrFo r d RdMountain Hill RdStarkey RdOld Red Eye Rd Hawkins RdMcC ormick Rd Silas Dodd Ln A fto n R d B ru mfield R d Cane Creek PkwyAnderson Rd Terry RdRo s e St Wyatts RdCherrystone Lake Rd Walkers Well RdMaysville Rd M c D a n i e l R d River Ridge Rd Ho pewe ll RdRandol ph Dr S y c a more R d Riddle Rd Mot l eys Mi ll RdMotleys Rd S u n s e t D r Fruitridge Dr Columbus Rd M a rin a D rTwin Arch DrConcord RdCrane RdSandy Creek Rd C r o w n R d Maple RdSpring Buck CirSugar Barbour Rd G r e e n F a rm R d Sandy Rd Mountain Run RdCott o n Pa t c h RdMill Run RdHodnetts RdSandy River RdGrit Rd Pickaway RdW ilk e rs o n R d Dabney House RdStone Mill RdOwens Mill Rd B e n n e tt C irBrushy Mountain RdHut son RdCava lr y Rd Wade Rd Cody RdEa so me Rd Double Creek RdInman RdSandy Creek Church Rd Cobbs Knob RdLo op R d Laurel Grove Rd Moorefield Bridge RdHillside RdPeach Orchard Rd Fe r g uson R d Countryside Dr Ringgold Depot Rd H ickory RdSprin g Rd Ivory Branch Rd Allan Creek RdLester RdMi dway RdBoxwood Rd Malmaison Rd Abbott Pl Robinhood Rd B e rry v ille R d Izaak Walton RdGraves Bridge RdHunters LnRed Rd H in e s v ille R d Weatherford DrN Flint Hill Rd Music St Vandola DrGallows Rd W Sunrise DrMill Creek Rd Mountain RdCedar Hill RdS to n y M ill S c h o o l R d Upper Mountain RdSummerset Rd NRidgeway RdLaniers Mill RdSailors Creek RdHa r bo r Dr Paisley RdWhite Ridge RdSnowberry RdMountain DrRobertson RdGap Rd Hodnetts Mill Rd Piney Grove Rd Hickeys Rd Mapleton Dr Bearskin Rd W h ite Fall R d Water Oak Rd T o m F o r k R d Sheva Rd Snakepath RdN M eado w s R dTelegraph RdColeman Mountain RdReeves Mill Rd K e e lin g D r Taylors Mill R d Church Rd Pleasant Gap DrHu n t in gto n T r l Cedar Rd Triangle School Rd R & L S m ith D rM o s c o R d Elkh o rn Rd Stony Mill RdZion Rd Fairview Rd B roo ksid e R dMarion RdR o c k s prin g s R d Bu r t on La ke Rd Wards RdScott Jacobs Memorial DrMartin DrGl envi ew Dr Weal Rd J a s m in e R d Sugartree Church Rd Banister RdRockford School Rd C o o k s b urg R d Green Pond RdGlade RdUnion Hall School RdDerby Rd Bibee RdDry Fork Rd Game Reserve Rd Birch Creek RdKerns Church RdStillmeadow RdFarmers RdJohnson Mill RdRinggold Church Rd Oak Hill RdPayneton Rd M ead o w s R d S M e a d o w s R d Wyatt Farm Rd Tucker RdYorkshire DrGolf Club RdHarmony RdEd munds Rd Mount Tabor RdOld Mine Rd Anderson Mill Rd Henrys Mill Rd Ir i s h R d Pocket Rd Piney R dShula Dr Dodson Rd W his p erin g Pin e s R d R ic e v ille R d Strader RdRoark Mill Rd Ca scade Mill RdJ ava R dSmith Mountain Rd Anderson Mill RdOxford RdLevel Run Rd Whitmell School Rd Markham Rd Pittsville Rd Dews RdM o ons RdSago Rd O ld H w y 2 9 Brights Rd Re nan R d Sl at esvi l l e RdMedical Center Rd B erry H ill R dCascade RdMusevill e RdRockford School RdStraightstone RdClimax RdDeer View Rd Grassland Dr B lu e R id g e D rS pring G arden RdChalk Level RdKentuck RdMount Cross Rd S Boston Hwy O ld R ich m on d R dE FranklinTpkeMain StN Main StS Main StMai n StM ain S tMiltonHwyDanville ExpyD a n ville E x p y Martinsville Hwy MartinsvilleHwy W Gretna Rd E G r e t n a R d Halifax Rd C a l l a n d s R d Franklin TpkeFranklin Tpke ¬«62 ¬«57 ¬«57 ¬«360 ¬«57 ¬«57 ¬«41 ¬«41 ¬«40 ¬«40 ¬«40 £¤58 £¤58 £¤29 £¤29 £¤29 £¤29 £¤360 £¤58 Chatham Gretna Hurt Blairs Motley MountHermon Sources: Esri, HERE, Garmin, USGS, Intermap, INCREMENT P, NRCan, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong), Esri Korea, Esri (Thailand), NGCC, (c) OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community Pittsylvania County Commission Districts - Plan B Minor Roads Secondary Roads Primary Roads Current Districts Places Districts 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 0 2 4 6 81Miles . 4.a.d Packet Pg. 29 Attachment: Plan B (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at Board's December Busines) S Boston Hwy O ld R ich m on d R dE FranklinTpkeMain StN Main StS Main StMai n StM ain S tMiltonHwyDanville ExpyD a n ville E x p y Martinsville Hwy MartinsvilleHwy W Gretna Rd E G r e t n a R d Halifax Rd C a l l a n d s R d Franklin TpkeFranklin Tpke S mith River Richmond BlvdHoll ywood RdCallands RdRinggold RdMount View RdRiver Run CirHarley LnJustin VisPeanut Rd Azalea LnMt Airy Elem CirCrabb Farm RdW in d s o r P lBell s DrLafayette Dr Oak Ridge DrGranville Ct Heffinger Ln Vandola Church Rd Curtis LnEmerson Rd Green Rock BrgTrojan LnKerns Mill RdTarpley PlWren Dr Clark St Halifax Rd Canary Ln Figure Eight RdP itt S t Miller Dr Beech Ln Oakridge CtMulberry Rd Wil son StToney StShadow Box Rd Quail RdPenhook Ln W P ro sp e c t S tFairview LnWi ndy LnRamsey RdG r a n d C tLane Rd Penny Ln Factory LnH u n dle y B ra n c h Maplewood Ct Cedar Ct Loghaven Rd Glenland Rd Re a lt y R d Chestnut Ave Owens RdSilver Creek Ct Bi g Hil l RdWells Ln P in e C ro ft C i r Go o d ma n L n Ringgold Depot Ln Crestvie w Ln Tuck RdS ta te R te 730 Kent Ln Johnson's Mill RdScott St Castle CtTransco LnGlory Dr Reservoir View TrlVandale DrPinetum RdBambi Ln Parker Pl P o p la r R d Wards Ln Cool Branch Rd Creasy St N e w to n L n M axey Ln Calvin RdDeerwood Tract CtSimpson Dr A dam s View LnN Davis DrM a r y L n Elbow RdSunset StOttawa LnLowland Dr I nc a Ln Hackberry RdWinston CirAlta StA d a m s L n Mill RdJacob PlOrchard DrForest CtCamney RdVictoria L n P i e r c e C tD an ie l Rd Corner RdDiscovery RdHazel LnSharon WayMeadowlark RdDodson LnMaybrook AveHowerton LnSwedwood DrM a y a R d W hitefall Rd Kadesh Ct Callahan Hill Rd Hearp Ln O wl L n A p ostolic Dr Keesee Rd Smith RdWalker Dr C ed ar C rest L nEcho LnLakeridge DrPleasant Dr Roach-Moore Ln S h e ld o n C tLake Point DrMiller LnSta t e R t e 7 4 3 Nalls St Banleys St Old Mayfield Rd Zebr a RdSylvan RdR u shin g B ran c h R d F a w n W a y Pudding Creek Rd B e lle O a k C tChatham Hall Ci rP rin c e to n D rOak Grove Dr S p a r t a n C t Early RdCa mb u ri d e s D rMagnolia Acres RdSl o w Wa t e r C t Wilkes Dr Sleeper LnD e erfield L n O ld O a k T rlCenter St M as h Bra n ch L n Greentree RdGobbler Ln E Sunset Dr W arehouse RdWoodbriar Ln E agle L nWalker Ridge Rd Harper Ln Priv Dr Or Prop Saunders Shop RdApplewood DrCross Creek LnJohnson Oakes RdD e erford Dr Harrier Ln Sassens Rdg Serenity LnN ine L ots Rd Pineview RdPeakland RdGardner St Exd Pear Tree Pl Page Rd Hundred Acre RdJessies LnLewis RdShields Rd S pa rt a n Ln Douglas DrHyler Cir Scruggsway Ter Holt St Johnson Farm RdPritchett Farm R d Pineview DrLewis Ln Ramp Rd Red Oak Rd Bu nker LnFriendship RdBarbour RdFoxfire Rd Reese DrTubbs L n Late RdOleander DrFalcon View DrLion Ln Gradual Grade Rd P ic k er L n Katie Hill RdDrury Ln Sugartree LnTardys CtFox Hunt Trl Brooks Ln Farm Rd Fall Creek Dr Fox TrlG ra n d v ie w F a r m R d Lakeview Forest Dr Old Mountain Rd Perdue DrAirport RdFairoaks RdStrawberry RdStallion Rd S p a n g le r D rS ton e M oun tain R dM a is o n D rOak Ridge Farm s Rd Ivy Cliff Rd T e rry L n Bowater DrW h iteh e a d S tWri gh t L nEasley Brown RdFay Lee Dr Dove Rd C a s e y C ir Yates Farm RdDaniel Ct Bennie DrWalnut Hill Rd F in g e r la k e R d Atlantic Timber Ln Railroad Ln G o o d vie w R d Moore Dairy Farm RdConcord Rd,N P o in t e L n Woodhaven DrF a i r wa y LnRidgeview R dOakland DrDogwood DrJefferson DrHyler Farm Ln J o s h R d Redd Ln Windsor TrlKristy Ln Brumfield Ct Constellation DrMulberry Trailer Park Lemon Ln Alle n Cree k R dIrby CirSkyline Girls RdCarter Dr Pinetum Ln River RdRawless Dr Homeport LnMarilla LnTriple Creek Farm RdBonny AveHorseshoe Rd Walnut RdLearner Ln White Dr Rocksprings LnClay Branch Rd Sycamore Creek Rd Treeline Rd T urn er L n Rorer St B ro w ning Ln Riverbend RdWi n d y Hill Ct Manna Hill Rd Four Pond Ter Rison St Newby LnSaddle Rd Hollys RdO w l C tBeckham CtAngie RdKeatts LnParker Rd WB rid le P a th T rlG osney Farm Rd Hemlock Dr O ld C a b in T r lMotleyEnglishs DrBent Cr eek RdInman DrLocust LnB a rke r Fa r m Rd H e n ry s M ill L n Collie TerLong CirC r a d d o c k L n Alle n D r Rosebud CtMorgan Ln Harpers Dairy RdJay Bird LnLu m pkin View Dr Hardy Creek LnIndustrial DrPear Tree RdCreeksview Ln Anderson PinesCar efr e e LnKeesee LnSquirrel RdTributary Rd Cheroke Ln Wil liam DrHunts Town Rd Oriole LnOak Crest RdCedar LnCollie StVirginia Ln Fox Berry Ln C e d ar Rid g e R d R Rou t e 7 2 8 R ob i n R i dg e Ct Bob Neal LnHamilton Tract LnLakeside Dr Chestnut Ridge LnCreek Bottom RdFalls LnR u b y L n Suburban DrBowe St Sweetgum LnSonshine DrTaylor Rd H o n e y w o o d Rd Wa y n e R o ber t s o n R d Wal t er Be ave rs P l Steam Way Brittany Rd Royale Dr Pine StK n o ttin g ha m W ayOak Ridge LnWarbler Ln Hill and Dale Farm R d B r u s h A r b o r C tFon t ai ne Rd Bat t er man RdStaunton River LndgCluster Pines Rd P e n in s u la P l Blue Jay LnOlde Hunting TrlReed Creek CtSl a u g h t e r A v e Gopher RdSwanson Ave L o n e s o m e P o n d R d Sidi ng Ci rMagnolia LnMeadows Farm RdStill Spring Dr Collins Farm RdUnicorn Dr Tow er Ln Sweden Fork Creek LnPvt Industrial RdDoe LnGolden LnJackson Hts Mallard Lake Dr Haymes RdHi gh Vi ew LnChickadee Rd Johns Run C reek R dWallace Ln Dav i s Fa r m RdPonderosa Dr L y n s k e y F a r m R d Gilbert RdCheyenne LnWi tcher RdCovington DrMacy Herndon Ln Tucks Cemetery RdAppletree RdHaymes LnFar m RdWin d y A cre s Trl Garden Dr Hudson Cir Rodgers RdWi l e s R d D airy L n Eskew Ln Hill Crest LnSharon Ln Sig n et R d Roy Ford Rd Cl ay Rd J a y B i r d H i l l R d Three Barn Rd R Route 725Rosewood CtIris LnElderberry LnGiles Ln Chestnut Ln Pi t chf or k RdLogan Ln Mohawk RdDr Mease Dr Cooksburg RdToshes RdBeach Hollow RdF E Keatts Ln Cascade Baptist Rd Buck Hill Rd Mountain Top DrHamilton Tract Rd B uckhorn D rDrawbridge RdMerricks Cv D arrell L n G u n n L nSimpson LnMeadowridge CtS Jamer son RdWalk Ln Rowland Dr M o u n t Z ion C h u rch R dW Withers Rd B e a rs k in S u b sta tio n R d W oodlawn HtsSilv er F o x R d J u n ior O aks R dCocke Ln Rosebud Rd O ake s & Sta nfiel d R d Big Sky Rd Hunting Ridge RdRicky Van Shelton Dr Gloria Ln Bennett St R is o n S t E x d Samuel Rd Lynn StL est er LnCundiff Ln Dewb e rr y R d Church LnS tra w b e rry C re e l L n K e s w ic k D r Mabe DrD a v is D rGrubb Rd Sugartree Manor Dr W H igh t ower R d Indian Trail RdRe es e Lo op RdDogwood Ln H u n te rs T rlBlack Bird Pl N o r t h s i d e D r Ferrell LnWorley Ct Faith Cove RdCompton RdFryingpan Ln C o u n t r y D r B a ile s s D r McNichols LnSt at on DrKyle RdL o n g Br a n c h Wa yPigg River RdBachelor Hall Ln D eerfie ld D rAdams Trl Centerville Rd L a k e sid e R d Sweden Fall s LnA lp in e Ln Junior Dodson Rd May Hardy Rd Stone Creek RdBloxsom RdPeach StW ashburn DrCamellia Ln Fairmont Rd H en ry Dr Basel RdBeechnut Rd Military DrThroughway Rd Wyatt DrLaurel Woods DrDogpatch LnGemstone LnWorley Ln Fla min g o R d School Rd Luster Rd L an d ru m R d Sam Adams Rd W Hurt Rd G e or g e R d Poplar TrceRiver Run Rd L o n g B ra n c h D r B o w l D r Spl endor s Gat e RdEagle Springs Rd B e a g le R d L a n ie r L n H ylto n L n River Ridge Ln E d dies L n N F o r k Dr Coffey St Longview Rd Easy Run RdBlankenship Rd M a p le D r Jasper Ln Brown RdApple LnCherrywood RdRiver Ridge DrCountryside CtBelair RdSkylock RdPittsville CirC a t aw b a D r Carson Lester Ln Tobacco RdS Briar Mountain Rd Two Pond Rd Sanctuary Bay DrRidge Rd Peacock Acres TrlRi dgeway DrStaunton River PlSwallow Rd Henry St H icko ry F o rest R d Princeton R dToshes Rd Stateline Bridge Rd Joe Carter Rd Brookside Ct Whitetail AveForestroad DrAdkins LnRay Mi ll RdMe a d d o c k L n Thompson RdHall Farmer RdJones Mil l RdN e w H o p e R d Wet Sleeve Creek Rd Hubbard RdHigh Meadow Cir S p rin g tr e e R d Al be c k Dr Bean Land RdB lacksmith Rd C e d a r S p r in g R d R o a r in g F o rk L a k e R d Meadow Brook Cir R etre at D r Sanctuary RdOakland DrWhitehorn Rd Vest RdMartin Rd C reeks B ank Rd Chaneys Stor e RdC e d a r Ga t e s Lo o p R d Cross Creek RdCompton DrDaniel LnJeanette DrPayne St W W itt RdRipley Dr Keatts Rd Grandad LnLog Cabin RdG e n tle P a s tu re R d Petty LnP rim itiv e B a p tis t R d W Rockwood Dr Hollyville Dr Jamerson Rd NPritchett LnWoodlawn Academy RdLong Short Rd Crossbow Dr Georges LnAl ber t Edmonds Dr Peaceful Ln Blair LnHerman Farmer RdWal lace WayS y c a m o re C ir Kendall Rd Henrys Mill Ct Horseshoe Dr Stowe Ln Logging RdCharming RdHankins LnHeron Poi nt e Dr Sunshine Acres Gretna Rd F o ster R d Winterhaven TrlSam Haley RdPonderosa Rd C ollie L n Cherokee Ln Oakwood DrM ockingbird Rd K elle y s D r D u n c a n D r Leesville Lake DrClarks Mill RdCoy Creek LnWoodview RdParker RdChippewa LnShotgun R dRocky Knoll LnMarson RdD ee p R u n R d Deerwood DrRed Ha wk L nHoneybee Rd L iv esto ck RdWoodview DrColony Rd Chestnut Ridge RdWhit e Oak Mou nt ai n DrRed Hill RdMount Hermon Cir High Point Rd Cedar Rd Chan e ys St or e RdG l e n n B ro w n R d C ava li e r RdChesapeake Dr S R iver R d Mountain View Shores Dr Floyd Smith Rd D elta D rM a n gru m s R dD e er H a v e n D r Buford RdPlaycation Retreat Cir Al mon d RdArnn LnNeal Davis RdJackson Ln Camp Branch Rd McNeely LnCross St i tch RdGammon Lake Rd E S to re L n Childress RdOttawa DrOwen RdAstin LnCemetery Rd O ld C a b in R d Robertson LnLakevie w Dr B e rry R d H e r n d o n L n Orange RdIona Rd Rigney Cir Laurel Ln Vance Hill Rd Tight Squeeze Rd Sandy Bottom Rd Peytonsburg R d Adams Farm Ln H ed ge R d Lee Ave Hu nt e r Rd Keens RdHighwayview RdR oach M e m orial Dr Liberty Rd Foxridge Rd Cherrystone RdMar t i n RdAvendale RdValley Rd S h e llh o r s e R dGordon RdB u r n e tt H o o d R d S Flint Hill Rd Raven Hollow Rd Coxs Store Rd B Jones RdDeer Track Farm RdHundley DrW S pencer R d Kendrick Rd Moores DrPinecroft RdRichardson LnHom estead TrlCedar Forest Rd Deercrest LnBobby Ln Dr Edward Williams Rd L e f t w ich S t Happy Ln Mic h a u x R d Cardwell LnMelon Rd Hutcherson Rd C h e stn ut L e v el L nDaisy Payne LnBassett Ln Owl Rd Jasper Wood Rd P a n n ell Dr Owl Dr Easley Rd Little Creek RdE W i tt R d Bennett DrF C Beverly RdM o s c h le r D rMaurakis RdFrancis Rd Millsville LnHither LnGalveston RdHarper RdTurkeycock Mountain Rd Jacobs RdB uck Track R d Star L a n d D r Al derso n Rd O liv e rs LnGammon s L a k e R d Azalea Dr W Maple Dr Oliver Rd N Briar Mountain RdHoney Rd Emery Rd Carter Lodge Rd Logwood AveBrownville Heights LnMerc u ry R d Magnolia RdHines Chapel RdGentlemans Ridge Rd Irby Rd Loblolly Dr Garrison Rdg Buck Horne RdM eado w view D rMill Creek RdRockcreek RdWatlington RdJohnson Rd Moses Mill Rd G andy RdSpaniel Rd Mitchell Rd M il l s t r ea m D rDaltons Farm LnFriendly Dr County Rd Dry Bridge RdColes RdRiceville Ct Maple Springs Dr La wless Creek R dTomahawk Mill RdShawnee RdColeman RdFall Creek RdFarmers Mountain Rd Wynell Dr Tightsqueeze Rd B a rn R d W F o rk R dC o u r t R d Plantation DrProspect RdOld Quarry RdDavid Giles LnRainbow LnT o ma h a w k Creek R d St one RdMill B r a n c h R d M il a m R d L o o mfi x e r L a k e Rd Old Hickory LnDaybreak TerG ravel Hill R dGreen Bay Rd Doctor Milams Rd Spruse Rd Ril ey Farm RdWalnut Creek RdTunstall High RdSmith Rd Flat Top Cove RdCooper RdClover Rd Barker RdSportsman Rd Slayton RdBen A nnie RdAndre w Rd Mountain LnDavis Rd Player RdWaller LnWeller LnLotus DrBelmort Dr Waller Rd Ferry Rd Bair Branch RdWi Powell RdEd Hardy Rd Jen nin gs D rLeaksville Junction RdE Hightower Rd Pounds RdElm Rd Clearview DrN Maple Rd Parrish Rd S ilv e r C re ek R dMac RdVictoria RdAstro Dr Dairy Vi ew RdTender LnBrandon Rd Kentuck Church Rd Hill Creek RdArmstrong RdCountry Cl ub RdOak Grove RdHubbard RdTransco Rd Motley Rd Yeatts Store Rd Locust Dr Hunting Hills RdW Giles RdBurke RdDarby RdFairview N Whit e Oa k C ir Hermosa Rd Pine Lake Rd Beverly Heights RdDouble Bridge Rd Lark Dr Tates Mill RdC a m p v ie w R d H o me ste a d R d Ridgecrest DrFo r d RdMountain Hill RdStarkey RdOld Red Eye Rd Hawkins RdMcC ormick Rd Silas Dodd Ln A fto n R d B ru mfield R d Cane Creek PkwyAnderson Rd Terry RdRo s e St Wyatts RdCherrystone Lake Rd Walkers Well RdMaysville Rd M c D a n i e l R d River Ridge Rd Ho pewe ll RdRandol ph Dr S y c a more R d Riddle Rd Mot l eys Mi ll RdMotleys Rd S u n s e t D r Fruitridge Dr Columbus Rd M a rin a D rTwin Arch DrConcord RdCrane RdSandy Creek Rd C r o w n R d Maple RdSpring Buck CirSugar Barbour Rd G r e e n F a rm R d Sandy Rd Mountain Run RdCott o n Pa t c h RdMill Run RdHodnetts RdSandy River RdGrit Rd Pickaway RdW ilk e rs o n R d Dabney House RdStone Mill RdOwens Mill Rd B e n n e tt C irBrushy Mountain RdHut son RdCava lr y Rd Wade Rd Cody RdEa so me Rd Double Creek RdInman RdSandy Creek Church Rd Cobbs Knob RdLo op R d Laurel Grove Rd Moorefield Bridge RdHillside RdPeach Orchard Rd Fe r g uson R d Countryside Dr Ringgold Depot Rd H ickory RdSprin g Rd Ivory Branch Rd Allan Creek RdLester RdMi dway RdBoxwood Rd Malmaison Rd Abbott Pl Robinhood Rd B e rry v ille R d Izaak Walton RdGraves Bridge RdHunters LnRed Rd H in e s v ille R d Weatherford DrN Flint Hill Rd Music St Vandola DrGallows Rd W Sunrise DrMill Creek Rd Mountain RdCedar Hill RdS to n y M ill S c h o o l R d Upper Mountain RdSummerset Rd NRidgeway RdLaniers Mill RdSailors Creek RdHa r bo r Dr Paisley RdWhite Ridge RdSnowberry RdMountain DrRobertson RdGap Rd Hodnetts Mill Rd Piney Grove Rd Hickeys Rd Mapleton Dr Bearskin Rd W h ite Fall R d Water Oak Rd T o m F o r k R d Sheva Rd Snakepath RdN M eado w s R dTelegraph RdColeman Mountain RdReeves Mill Rd K e e lin g D r Taylors Mill R d Church Rd Pleasant Gap DrHu n t in gto n T r l Cedar Rd Triangle School Rd R & L S m ith D rM o s c o R d Elkh o rn Rd Stony Mill RdZion Rd Fairview Rd B roo ksid e R dMarion RdR o c k s prin g s R d Bu r t on La ke Rd Wards RdScott Jacobs Memorial DrMartin DrGl envi ew Dr Weal Rd J a s m in e R d Sugartree Church Rd Banister RdRockford School Rd C o o k s b urg R d Green Pond RdGlade RdUnion Hall School RdDerby Rd Bibee RdDry Fork Rd Game Reserve Rd Birch Creek RdKerns Church RdStillmeadow RdFarmers RdJohnson Mill RdRinggold Church Rd Oak Hill RdPayneton Rd M ead o w s R d S M e a d o w s R d Wyatt Farm Rd Tucker RdYorkshire DrGolf Club RdHarmony RdEd munds Rd Mount Tabor RdOld Mine Rd Anderson Mill Rd Henrys Mill Rd Ir i s h R d Pocket Rd Piney R dShula Dr Dodson Rd W his p erin g Pin e s R d R ic e v ille R d Strader RdRoark Mill Rd Ca scade Mill RdJ ava R dSmith Mountain Rd Anderson Mill RdOxford RdLevel Run Rd Whitmell School Rd Markham Rd Pittsville Rd Dews RdM o ons RdSago Rd O ld H w y 2 9 Brights Rd Re nan R d Sl at esvi l l e RdMedical Center Rd B erry H ill R dCascade RdMusevill e RdRockford School RdStraightstone RdClimax RdDeer View Rd Grassland Dr B lu e R id g e D rS pring G arden RdChalk Level RdKentuck RdMount Cross Rd ¬«62 ¬«57 ¬«57 ¬«360 ¬«57 ¬«57 ¬«41 ¬«41 ¬«40 ¬«40 ¬«40 £¤58 £¤58 £¤29 £¤29 £¤29 £¤29 £¤360 £¤58 Chatham Gretna Hurt Blairs Motley MountHermon Sources: Esri, HERE, Garmin, USGS, Intermap, INCREMENT P, NRCan, Esri Japan, METI, Esri China (Hong Kong), Esri Korea, Esri (Thailand), NGCC, (c) OpenStreetMap contributors, and the GIS User Community Pittsylvania County Commission Districts - Plan C Minor Roads Secondary Roads Primary Roads Current Districts Places Districts 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 0 2 4 6 81Miles . 4.a.e Packet Pg. 30 Attachment: Plan C (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at Board's December Busines) First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Jodi Via jodicarter83@gmail.com 24566 Dan River I am supportive of either Plan B or Plan C for the redistricting. I'm currently in the Dan River district but would love to be part of the Banister district, as it's the district I work in and frequent more often. Plan B Carl Davis carlmichael85@gmail.com 24586-3845 Dan River Plan B does not appear to gerrymander the count/district the worst. Plan B Curtis England England4.wvu@gmail.com 24563 Staunton River Plan B makes the most since to me. Not sure a Vote counts for anything in Virginia anymore anyways. Plan B Kathryn Wilton romeokat@gmail.com 24557 Banister I would prefer either Plan B or C; Plan A is similar to what we currently have and is a disgusting example of gerrymandering. Please keep redistricting simple and sensible: go with either Plan B or C. Plan B Lisa Jones ljones4711@gmail.com 24054 Tunstall I prefer plan C Plan C David Wilton dave@stricklers.org 24557 Banister Plan B or C would be fine. Plan A, I should submit to Wikipedia as the definition of jerrymandering. Plan C Joshua Austin Joshua.austint@gmail.com 24073 Banister All of these proposed maps are rattled with gerrymandering and should be redrawn. Danielle Feeney Danielley2831@hotmail.com 24540 Tunstall B and C are clear gerrymandering. Plan A serves so purpose. Districts should be left how they are currently. Plan A Jennifer Arnn elliottjenny1009@gmail.com 24540 Westover Please keep districts as close to they are currently, with only minor changes. Thank y’all Plan A PITTSYLVANIA COUNTY 2021 REDISTRICTING PUBLIC COMMENT FEEDBACK TO DATE Nov. 1 - 19, 2021 Page 1 4.a.f Packet Pg. 31 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Elizabeth Boswell Meand3ajs@yahoo.com 24139 Callands-Gretna Plan B is more suitable due to my particular area. Plan A puts my address on the line with Stanton river in which I do not want. I see confusion with plan A also in the long run as the area may increases in population. Plan B Richard Donnelly robinridge2@gmail.com Callands-Gretna I support Plan B. Plan B Rhonda McFalls Mcfallsx6@comcast.net 24540 Westover My children attend Dan River High school and therefore I should have a say as to who serves on the board. It is not about equality of the districts. You should be able to vote on matters that concern your area. Anything less takes away my 19th amendment rights. I vote for no plan currently suggested as none of them allow me to vote in the currently school district my chirldren attend. Page 2 4.a.f Packet Pg. 32 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Brenda Williams bmwilcox@yahoo.com 24586 Dan River If all districts currently outlined have been accurately polled for number of residences all 3 of the proposed districts should qualify. Maybe I'm not seeing the bigger picture. Plan A seems to be the plan that is least affected by the changes based on current poll area's. One needs to keep in mind how sections of all the current areas have a residence count that will quickly change with the land development in some of those districts that are underway or planned in the near future. I suppose my question would be when where the residence's counted for the proposed new area's ans does these numbers include current new construction or planned construction of new residences? Plan A Brian McFalls Mcfallsx5@gmail.com 24540 Westover I don't understand how my kids attend Dan River schools yet I vote for Westover district. I don't agree with any of the options presented. Maybe you should redistrict according to the schools that you have already assigned/districted. That way those that have children attending those schools can vote for a representative in their actual district. It's not rocket science. Seth Scarce seth.scarce@pittgov.org 24540 Chatham-Blairs Plan B Plan B Janice Inman Janiceinman1@icloud.com 24540 Chatham-Blairs Plan A Plan A Christina Scarce cke02071992@hotmail.com 24540 Tunstall . Plan B Tricia Waller vols10ec@hotmail.com 24565 Banister N/A Plan B Natalie Hudgins ngoakes@gmail.com 24540 Chatham-Blairs N/A Plan B Page 3 4.a.f Packet Pg. 33 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Tammy Yeatts tammy.slugger@gmail.com 24527 Chatham-Blairs Only Plan A leaves us in the Chatham- Blairs district . That is where we want to stay. I have talked to people in the Banister district and they have to travel a long ways to vote. If you are planning on changing the districts like this you need to open more polling places if not it seems like you don't want people to vote because you are putting residents out by making them travel even further to vote. Thank you Plan A Joseph Merricks merricksj76@comcast.net 24540 Chatham-Blairs We would prefer to stay in the Chatham- Blair’s district mainly because we have more in common with the people of this district than the Westover district. Plan A Nikkia Fitzgerald nikkiarenea83@yahoo.com 24531-3502 Banister . Plan A Robin Rowland squabrowland@gmail.com 24557 Staunton River I think Plan C has the clearest lines. Plan C Audrey Myers luvneyesnay65@yahoo.com 24557 Staunton River I feel plan B or C puts me back where I belong and clears up the boundary lines. I was Callands-Gretna for years until the last redistreicting. I was then switched, but right across the road stayed Callands- Gretna. I live only 3.8 miles from Gretna but 12.3 miles to where I have to vote. Plan C Page 4 4.a.f Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Robert Gilbert gilbertthg@aol.com 24531 Banister I urge your consideration of Plan A, but with some modifications to increase the percentage of minorities. As Plan A now stands, the Black population only account for approx. 50.3 percent, down from the approx. 55 percent of the plan adopted in 2011. During the last redistricting in 2011, a representative group from the Black community met with the map drawers and was able to work to maintain a plan that better mirrored the "Voting Age population within the Black community and other mitigating factors that affect Black voters. I would urge that you allow such a representative group be allowed to meet with your map drawers to take another look for ways to make this happen again. The Banister District was created after the 1990 census for the distinct purpose of achieving one out of seven districts that would allow a level playing field to give minorities a fair chance to win, not to guarantee winning, but to give a fair chance to be elected. As history has proven, there was little cross- over voting when Black candidates ran for election. During the ensuing election, Mr. William Pritchett was narrowly elected in 1992, the first black ever to be elected as Plan A Page 5 4.a.f Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Brenda Bowman bbowman300@embarqmail.com 24549 Chatham-Blairs When you click on the 3 individual plans in the PDF format, the 7 districts are identified by color and the color key at the bottom of the page identifies the color districts by numbers. Most citizens do not know their district number. They only know it by name. I would suggest that the color key at the bottom of the page also identify the name of the district by the number. This would be more user- friendly for the average citizen making it easier to see exactly how the proposals affect their address. Thank you for your consideration. Lisa Campbell hummers1963@gmail.com 24557 Banister I prefer plan B Plan B Roy Ford r16ford@hotmail.com 24541 Westover I favor plan A because it offers the best opportunity to maintain a minority member on the Board. It may also have the best chance to avoid being challenged by the Justice Department. Plan A Page 6 4.a.f Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Charles Angier cangier@rsnet.org 24161 Chatham-Blairs As I viewed the work session of Nov. 16, I was surprised at the level of mandates and restrictions placed upon the localities by the state. I would suggest that everyone should view the Nov. 16 work session and download the census and demographic information on the redistricting page before charges of gerrymandering are made. Plan A is the only one of the three that maintains a "majority-minority" district in Banister, thus the perceived gerrymandering. The other 2 plans make Banister as well as the other 6 districts more reflective of the overall county ethnic profile. Plan B splits Chatham into 3 districts and is almost as convoluted as Plan A. Plan C, though it does not define a majority-minority district, leaves Chatham intact, is the least convoluted and most conƟguous. Plan C Page 7 4.a.f Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Kelsie Myers kelsie.myers@pittgov.org 24557 Staunton River I feel Plan B better captures the areas with the boundary lines and cleans the map up without a lot of confusion. I used to be in the Callands-Gretna District, and across the road from me is still Callands- Gretna. I am much closer to Gretna (only 2.8 miles) than I am to the precinct where I vote (12 miles). Also, most of my business (grocery, restaurants) is conducted in the Gretna area. Plan B Page 8 4.a.f Packet Pg. 38 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Jason Ball jason.ball_va@yahoo.com 24531 Callands-Gretna Looking closely at the proposed maps, in my opinion proposal B is the best option for 2 critical reasons. First, it groups the districts best in groups of like-minded neighbors in defined boundaries which is the primary reason of the redistricting. Chatham is actually in the Chatham-Blairs district as opposed to option C. Callands is in its districts as an entity, as well as Westover and etc. Secondarily, there is less gerrymandering, or the appearance thereof in Option B. The NAACP mistakenly supported option A for better racial power in elections, which ironically is the definition of both gerrymandering and racism. In their request at the BOS meeting, they acknowledged that the minorities are in less population and more spread out in the population than in previous censuses. Fortunately, their dispersion into the rest of the community is the success of decades of integration. That success should not be hidden and deleted with narrow and long ethnically drawn boundaries that divides neighborhoods. Plan B William Shelhorse James.shelhorse@gmail.com 24540 Chatham-Blairs Hello I prefer plan B for redistricting. Mount Hermon shouldn’t be included with Brosville like A or Chatham like C. Plan B Howard Crump hscrump31@yahoo.com 24586 Dan River Plan A Plan A Timothy Rollison Theel50@yahoo.com 24563 Staunton River I support Plan A for the redistricting Plan A Page 9 4.a.f Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan First Name Last Name Email Address Zip Code Current District Feedback Preferred Plan Jennifer Ketchum jlketchum@chatmosscable.com 24541 Westover I have been in the Westover District since moving to my home in 1994 and am completely satisfied with remaining in the Westover district. I prefer Plan B but could be ok with Plan A if necessary. However, I am totally against Plan C for many reasons. I don’t like that Westover district would shrink by going with Plan C and have no interest in becoming in the Tunstall district. I voted for our Supervisor Ron Scearce and have been completely satisfied with everything he is doing to help our Westover district and want to remain living under his knowledge, helpfulness, and dedication of service. Thanks in advance for keeping Horseshoe Rd in the Westover district!!Plan B Patricia Bolton 24541 Westover I want to stay in the Westover District !! We like the closest fire department!Plan B Tim Cassell tpcassell@comcast.net 24541 Westover Leave us alone. I pick B. Plan B Lynn Newman lnewman57@gmail.com 24541 Westover Plan B Plan B Page 10 4.a.f Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan 1 Comment on Redistricting Plans A, B, and C and on Data for Current Districts I appreciate the opportunity to comment. Thank you. As I wrote in an email to Pittsylvania County Assistant Administrator Dave Arnold on November 5th, “Without racial ethnic data for the prison population, we cannot know the racial ethnic make-up of the prison-adjusted population of the current or proposed voting districts. The tables for ‘Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District %’ are wrong. To suggest they are accurate - or even helpful - is misleading.” The data provided in the Census 2020 Data Report for Pittsylvania County by ARCBridge Consulting and Training is incomplete. There is no “racial ethnic” data for the prison population. The four pages with data for Current Districts, Plan A, Plan B, and Plan C each show racial ethnic data for the districts before people are added or removed for the prison adjustment. The number of people in the racial/ethnic categories in each district add up to the district population total, not the prison-adjusted figure. If percentages for each racial/ethnic category were calculated as a percentage of the total population, the percentages would add up to 100%. Instead, the data in the tables titled "Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District %" are calculated using the “Prison-Adjusted” population total for each district. As a consequence, the percentages for each district add up to either more or less than 100%, depending on whether the prison adjustment added or subtracted people from the district. To suggest that these percentages provide useful information is wrong. It may be helpful to consider this simplified example: Suppose you have 10 pieces of fruit. 5 are apples. 5 are oranges. Apples, as a percentage of the total, equal 5 divided by 10, which equals 50%. Oranges, as a percentage of the total, equal 5 divided by 10, which equals 50%. Suppose you then “adjust” the total by taking away one piece of fruit. You now have 9 pieces of fruit. What is the new percentage of apples and oranges? If you don’t know whether the fruit taken away was an apple or an orange, you can’t know the new percentage of apples and oranges. If you were to use the type of calculation we see in the Census 2020 Data Report for Pittsylvania County, you would erroneously divide 5 by 9 and get 55.55% for apples and 55.55% for oranges … the wrong answer. (You have the same problem if you add a piece of unknown fruit: 5 divided by 11 gives 45.45% apples and 45.45% oranges … again, the wrong answer. Now consider data for Current Districts in the ARCBridge report. As an example, look at District 3, the current Banister District: The “Total” population of the current Banister District is 8,282. The Non-Hispanic White population is 3,679. The percentage Non-Hispanic White is 3,679 divided by 8,282, which equals 44.42%. Katie Whitehead Current election district: Chatham-Blairs Date submitted: November 11, 2021 4.a.f Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at 2 The Non-Hispanic Black population is 4,164. The percentage Non- Hispanic Black is 4,164 divided by 8,282, which equals 50.28%. The other categories, which include Hispanic, “2+ Race” (mixed race), and others, total 439. The percentage “Other” is 439 divided by 8,282, which equals 5.30%. The three percentages total 100%. (44.42% + 50.28% + 5.30% = 100%) The “Prison-Adjusted” population of the current Banister District is 7,621. The table titled "Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District %" inexplicably uses this number to calculate percentages. This table is meaningless. Non-Hispanic White: 3,679 divided by 7,621 = 48.27% Non-Hispanic Black: 4,169 divided by 7,621 = 54.70% Other: 439 divided by 7, 621 = 5.76% Total: 108.73% The difference between the Total population (8,282) and the Prison-Adjusted population (7,621) is 661 people. The Census 2020 Data Report for Pittsylvania County does not identify the race/ethnicity of these people. We cannot calculate the "Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District %" for the current Banister District or for any other district. This same mistake is made in all the current districts and in all districts in the three proposed redistricting plans – Plan A, Plan B, and Plan C. The tables for ‘Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District %’ are wrong. To suggest they are accurate - or even helpful - is misleading. So, what should the Pittsylvania County Administration and Board of Supervisors do? Acknowledge that there has been a big mistake. Don’t pretend that ARCBridge’s Census and Demographic Analysis is meaningful. Such pretense only makes the error worse. 1. Inform the public that you do not know the racial and ethnic percentages for the proposed or current prison-adjusted voting districts. IF racial and ethnic data is available for people who are incarcerated, 2. Ask ARCBridge to revise the data tables in their Census and Demographic Analysis and resubmit their report. 3. Publicize the revised report (with accurate racial/ethnic percentages) and extend the comment period. IF racial and ethnic data is not available for people who are incarcerated, 4. Remove the data tables titled "Racial Ethnic Composition of Each District %" from the Census and Demographic Analysis available at the Pittsylvania County Administration Building and on the County’s website. 5. Publicize the corrected redistricting analysis (omitting racial/ethnic percentages) and extend the public comment period. Katie Whitehead Current election district: Chatham-Blairs Date submitted: November 11, 2021 4.a.f Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: Redistricting Feedback To Date For Web Publishing (2876 : Selection of Redistricting Plan for Advertisement for Adoption at