03-20-2018 Joint Finance and Fire and Rescue Committee Meeting - Draft
1
MINUTES
JOINT MEETING
PITTSYLVANIA COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
FINANCE COMMITTEE
AND
THE PITTSYLVANIA COUNTY FIRE & RESCUE POLICIES AND
PROCEDURES COMMITTEE
MAIN CONFERENCE ROOM
COUNTY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING
TUESDAY, MARCH 20, 2018
3:00 PM
The meeting was opened at 3:00 by Mr. Blackstock, Chairman of the Finance
Committee of the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors.
Present
Mr. Blackstock, Chairman, Finance Committee and member of Fire & Rescue
Committee, Board of Supervisors
Mr. Ronald Scearce, Finance Committee & Fire & Rescue Committee, Board of
Supervisors
Absent
Mr. Davis, Finance Committee, Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors
Mr. Warren, Finance Committee, Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors
Mr. Barber, Fire & Rescue Committee, Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors
Guests
Mr. Farmer, Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors
Mr. Smitherman, County Administrator
Mr. Hicks, Assistant County Administrator
Kaylyn McCluster, Deputy Clerk
J. Vaden Hunt, County Attorney
The meeting was suspended at 3:03 because lack of attendance for quorum.
Mr. Warren, Finance Committee, Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors,
arrived at 3:13 and the meeting was resumed.
A motion was made by Mr. Warren, seconded by Mr. Blackstock to approve the
agenda.
2
Mr. Smitherman started by saying that Fire & Rescue adds about $1 million and
one employee to the budget and also states that in the new proposed budget there are
certain basic minimum requirements such as using our purchasing policy, using the
incident command system, maintaining an active duty roster, and maintaining a 70%
response rate. He then directed discussion to Mr. Slemp regarding the proposed budget
for Fire & Rescue Agencies and the feedback that he has gotten from that matter. Mr.
Slemp spoke about how him and some of the fire and rescue agencies had been going
around and doing needs assessments in the County to try and determine things that the
different agencies needed, and also things that they didn’t need. There were certain
places where they were able to save money by lending out supplies from one agency to
the other. He spoke highly of how they were all coming together and working together
more every day. He said that he was able to tweak the budget some and save some
money in certain line items. He did point out that not all fire stations are able to provide
their firefighters with their own masks, which is a major health and safety issue. Mr.
Slemp states that there are some concerns with the new budget, but that they are all in
agreement that they are all in the same place and they all want to get better. He turns
discussion over to Scottie Adams.
Mr. Adams spoke and requested for support of their budget if they could stay
within the budget and work with Mr. Slemp on areas that needed improvement. He also
thanked the County Administrator for putting that into the budget. He stated that he felt
that the needs assessment needed to be done across the board so they had visited every
fire and rescue squad in the County. He stated that there were currently 156 vehicles on
the insurance, not counting the SOT trailers. After visiting all agencies, they were able to
find savings and recommendations for the insurance and will be presenting them to the
Fire/Rescue Association and then get it back to the Board. An example was given of one
fire station having 14 trucks, but the County only insuring 10 of them. The other 4 would
be left up to the agency to either get rid of or pay for the insurance themselves. There are
21 fire stations and 12 rescue squads within the County, and the argument was made that
depending on the location and call volumes, not every station would need the same
amount of trucks to be insured. Mr. Blackstock asked for clarification on the trucks that
would be paid for by the agency, and Mr. Adams stated that they would like to keep the
trucks on the County insurance but would like for it to come off the block funding. Mr.
Hunt said that he thought that could be worked out legally. Mr. Warren said that he’s
understanding it that each department is falling below the 7 trucks per locality on
average, and Mr. Adams confirmed that. Mr. Adams requested that they present their
proposal to Fire and Rescue and then present it back to the Board. Mr. Slemp said that
very little would change since they are already on the insurance policy and Mr. Adams
said that they were planning to meet on Tuesday to adjust the value on some of the trucks
to reflect what they are really worth, and hopefully that will reduce some of that cost as
well.
Mr. Adams stated that there were 11 agencies present at their workshop and no
one wanted to sign the service agreement. He said that their goal is a 12-minute response
time. They do not have members who stay at their rescue buildings and they also don’t
want their members running 100mph down the road to try and make that response time.
3
He stated that they do want accountability, but that they don’t agree with the service
contract. They want to work with Mr. Slemp and also report back to the Board monthly.
Mr. Blackstock made a suggestion that the Fire and Rescue agencies sit down
with Mr. Slemp and have a working document for the Board to go through so that they
can look at it and work through their differences. Mr. Adams agreed and said that they
were for that. Mr. Slemp said that he felt that the agencies are worried about the
“contract” part, and that is their fear. Mr. Smitherman suggested that a memorandum of
agreement be made instead of a contract.
Mr. Warren questioned the mechanism of being able to count the first 10-minute
responses and Mr. Adams stated that they don’t have a system that will record that. Mr.
Scearce asks if there was any way to put a note in the system to record who was actually
the first to respond, even in personal vehicles, but Mr. Adams said that they can’t input
that into the system that they currently have. Mr. Warren states that it seems that the
responders are actually doing a better job than the numbers are really reflecting and he is
more concerned about actual on the scene time versus response time. The downfall is
that there is no where in the CAD system to input this information. Mr. Slemp said that
right now they do not have a centralized system that can do this type of thing but does
want that type of system in the future.
Mr. Adams then spoke on the titling of vehicles. There is a vehicle going to
Renan any day and there is a concern titling the vehicle to the County and to Renan and
would rather have an agreement versus a joint title. He gave a handout from Campbell
County Board of Supervisors as an example. Mr. Blackstock voiced his concern that the
taxpayer previously has no claim that the equipment that has been bought as a board. He
thinks it’s not fair and just not smart and that there could be some hang ups with the
County’s name on every vehicle title. He stated that he wouldn’t have a problem if a
document were developed where it was signed by the appropriate officials from the
agency as well as the County Attorney and County Administrator saying that the County
would be able to get the money back legally if something were to happen. Mr. Warren
agreed with Mr. Blackstock’s statement and he commended Fire and Rescue for their
cooperation and collaboration. Mr. Adams stated that he wants to come up with a set of
specs to report back and Mr. Warren stated that he wants to be kept in the loop on
purchases, because Economic Development could affect the need for services in certain
areas. Mr. Smitherman said that they could work with Mr. Hunt and Mr. Slemp on the
document for titling.
Mr. Scearce asked if grant money would be available for the mask issue and Mr.
Slemp said that the money that was put into the budget was for new air bottles, but some
of those people were able to find grant money for that so they are hoping they will be
able to use that money for the masks. Mr. Farmer commended Fire & Rescue for all their
hard work.
4
A motion to adjourn was made by Mr. Blackstock, seconded by Mr. Warren. The
meeting was adjourned at 4:02 p. m.